Author: Amanda Ahne
Bi-Weekly Geopolitical Report – The Oil Weapon Returns (October 2, 2023)
Bill O’Grady | PDF
Oil is arguably the most critical commodity. Although food is perhaps more essential to life, most food production today is dependent on fossil fuels. Daniel Yergin’s epic history of oil, The Prize,[1] examines who had oil, who needed oil, and what they did to secure it. Due to oil’s importance, there has often been a geopolitical element to the commodity. We believe we are seeing yet another episode of oil being used for geopolitical purposes.
In this report, we open the discussion with two examples of using oil supplies for political purposes. Next, we offer a short history of oil in the Middle East. From there, we will examine recent developments. With this background in place, we will then look at how the power of oil affects presidential approval ratings. We will also show how OPEC+, especially the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) and Russia, are using oil supplies to further their geopolitical goals. As always, we will conclude with market ramifications.
[1] Yergin, Daniel. (1991). The Prize: The Epic Quest for Oil, Money, and Power. New York, NY: Free Press.
Don’t miss our other accompanying podcasts, available on our website and most podcast platforms: Apple | Spotify | Google
Daily Comment (October 2, 2023)
by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash
[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF
Our Comment today opens with a recap of the U.S. Congress’s last-minute deal on Saturday to avert a partial government shutdown. We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including news on the Chinese economy, prospects for tighter monetary policy in Japan, and falling steel prices in the U.S. as the United Auto Workers continue their strike against the country’s top auto manufacturers.
U.S. Fiscal Policy: With just minutes to spare before the federal government would have run out of funding on Saturday night, the House and Senate approved a stopgap bill that will provide for spending at current levels to mid-November, giving Democrats and Republicans more time to negotiate over full-year appropriations. The breakthrough came as Republican House Speaker McCarthy shifted gears and put forward a stopgap bill that Democrats could accept, and that the Senate was unwilling to reject.
- The stopgap spending bill has prevented a partial shutdown of the federal government, but perhaps only temporarily. If lawmakers can’t agree by mid-November on a budget for the fiscal year that started Sunday, a disruptive shutdown is still possible.
- Meanwhile, hard-right Republicans in the House have vowed to launch a vote to oust McCarthy for failing to implement their cherished spending cuts and other conservative goals. It is not yet clear whether they will be successful in that effort.
China-Taiwan: People who monitor aircraft tracking sites say a Chinese military plane recently performed an unusual maneuver in which it closely followed and then dove beneath a civilian airliner as it flew close to Taiwanese waters. By flying directly beneath the civilian aircraft, the military plane temporarily dropped off ground-based tracking radar, suggesting the Chinese were practicing the maneuver as a way to keep their military aircraft from being tracked by Taiwanese radar in the event of a conflict.
China: In a win for President Xi’s program to clean up the country’s semiconductor industry, the former head of the state-backed computer chip giant Tsinghua Unigroup (600100.SS, CNY, 7.27) has plead guilty to corruption charges. The executive, Zhao Weiguo, apparently misappropriated state-owned assets valued at more than $60 million through shady real estate deals and similar crimes. Besides showing how Xi has made the semiconductor industry a new target of his anticorruption program, the case also illustrates how corruption has been one factor keeping the industry from catching up to its rivals in the West.
- Separately, the official purchasing managers’ index for manufacturing rose to a seasonally adjusted 50.2 in September, compared with 49.7 in August. The official PMI for the nonmanufacturing industries rose to 51.7 from 51.0. Both gauges are now above the 50.0 level that signals expanding activity. The PMI figures suggest the Chinese economy may have gotten through its recent rough patch and is growing again.
- All the same, that doesn’t necessarily mean the economy is growing rapidly. Growth is still sluggish because of problems such as weak consumer demand, high debt levels, poor demographics, and “de-risking” moves by foreign companies.
- Indeed, the World Bank today released new forecasts showing it expects Chinese gross domestic product to increase just 4.4% in 2024, after stripping out price changes. That’s down from the institution’s forecast of 4.8% in April.
- With weaker growth in China, the World Bank said it cut its growth forecast for the broader East Asia and Pacific regions to 4.5% in 2024, versus expected growth of 5.0% in 2023. Such poor growth rates would be among the region’s worst in the last five decades.
Japan: In the minutes of the Bank of Japan’s policy meeting last month, several officials said they were seeing progress on bringing consumer price inflation up to target in a sustainable way and indicated they should start planning to end their ultra-easy monetary policy. The minutes have intensified speculation that the BOJ will soon tighten monetary policy by eliminating its negative short-term interest rate and loosening up its control over longer-term bond yields.
United Kingdom: The Conservative Party has opened its annual conference, with some participating officials warning that Prime Minister Sunak will have to do more to retain power at the next elections and others clearly jostling for position to potentially unseat him in the future. For example, some officials are clamoring for tax cuts. On the eve of the meetings, Home Secretary Suella Braverman and Business Secretary Kemi Badenoch both floated the idea that the U.K. pulling out of the United Nations Convention on Human Rights was so the country could have a freer hand in blocking and deporting refugees.
Slovakia: In parliamentary elections over the weekend, former Prime Minister Robert Fico and his Russia-friendly, populist Smer Party won about 23% of the vote, comfortably ahead of the Ukraine-friendly, liberal Progressive Slovakia Party and its 18%. However, an even more Russia-friendly, far-right party that likely would have allied with Smer failed to win any seats in parliament, so Fico could have an uphill battle to form a governing coalition.
Serbia-Kosovo: U.S. officials have warned that Serbia is massing tanks, artillery, and other military equipment on the border with the breakaway province of Kosovo, in a move that points to a possible new Balkan war. Serbian President Aleksandar Vučić has denied that he intends to send Serbian troops into Kosovo but given the worsening of tensions between Serbia and Kosovo over the last few years, we cannot discount the possibility of a destabilizing new war in the Balkans.
U.S. Bond Market: The Wall Street Journal today carries a useful article with multiple charts explaining the recent surge in bond yields. As we had been warning, bond yields prior to late summer had seemed much lower than they should have been. Now that investors have focused on factors like the economy’s relatively good economic growth (for now), its persistent price pressures, and the Fed’s intention to keep interest rates higher for longer, it should be no surprise that bond yields have surged. As of this morning, the yield on the benchmark 10-year Treasury note has risen to 4.637%, its highest level since 2007, while the 2-year note has risen to 5.117%.

U.S. Steel Market: New reporting shows the United Auto Workers’ strike against the country’s top three automakers has slammed the demand for steel, contributing to a 40% drop in its price over the last several months. Of course, steel demand is also likely waning as overall economic growth slows and the economy looks set to fall into recession in the coming months.
Daily Comment (September 29, 2023)
by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash
[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF
Good morning! Today’s Comment will begin with a discussion of the potential for a soft landing, Europe’s budget problems, and an update on government shutdown talks. As usual, our report also provides an overview of the latest domestic and international data releases.
New Economic Fears: As investors embrace the possibility of a soft landing, there are growing signs that economic expansion is losing steam.
- The pandemic did not distort the economy as much as many had feared, according to a benchmark revision. Average U.S. economic activity growth between 2017 and 2022 was revised upwards from 2.1% to 2.2%. This slight upward revision suggests that the reporting during that period was relatively accurate. However, the underlying details show that there were still some noticeable changes. Household savings levels were revised downwards by about $1.1 trillion, although much of this update happened in the years prior to the pandemic. Meanwhile, the personal consumption price index showed that inflation rose 4.1% in 2022, above the previously reported 3.7%.
- Despite the slight change in GDP figures which reaffirmed economists’ beliefs that the economy has been more resilient since leaving the pandemic, the future remains less clear. Consumption has remained stable throughout 2023 but has decelerated in four of the five previous quarters. This shift in purchases reflects households switching from expensive durable goods to cheaper services. As a result, over 56% of the economists surveyed believe that consumption will decline in the first quarter of 2024, while 21% believe that the contractions could start as soon as the final quarter of 2023. Since it accounts for a little over a third of GDP, a significant drop in consumer spending may push the economy into a downturn.
(Source: DailyMail)
- Persistent strikes, rising oil prices, and delays in the impact of interest rates raise the risk of a hard landing. These headwinds are likely to exacerbate an already vulnerable economy. However, barring an outlier event, such as a war or a government default on its debt, the next recession may not be as bad as the previous two. The pandemic drop in the labor force suggests that workers who are laid off will have an easier time finding work than in typical downturns, and business investment will likely receive a boost from manufacturing. As a result, we are optimistic that equities are unlikely to be severely affected by a slowdown in economic activity.
What Deficit? The euro bloc may face challenges in getting its members to comply with budget limits by its desired deadline.
- The eurozone is expected to reinstate its 3% deficit target in early 2024, but two major economies, Italy and France, are not ready. Italy’s deficit is projected to be 4.4% of GDP, and France’s is projected to be around 4.3%. These shortfalls come as the eurozone prepares to return to rules that were put on hold due to the pandemic. French President Emmanuel Macron has struggled to pass a budget due to his party lacking a majority. Meanwhile, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s right-wing party still plans to follow through on its tax cut promises. It is not clear how strictly the bloc will enforce the rules, but it is likely to lead to significant friction between members.
- Concerns over rising deficits in the eurozone have led to a jump in European bond yields. The spread between the Italian and German 10-year government bonds, a gauge of financial stress, has climbed to a six-month high. The sharp increase in interest rates is due to concerns that the European Central Bank (ECB) will have to keep rates higher for longer to fight inflation, as well as the potential for an oil price shock. The rise in borrowing will likely exacerbate concerns that the region is headed for recession over the next coming months.

- Though a downturn is widely anticipated, governments have limited options to soften the blow. Policymakers at the ECB are hesitant to pivot from their hawkish stance, as inflation shows signs of returning. Government budget constraints will likely prevent another round of fiscal stimulus. The outlook for Europe over the next three months is bleak, and any improvement will depend on member states’ willingness to compromise on deficits or a complete reversal in monetary policy. Such uncertainty will likely weigh on the euro as investors try to gauge what is next for the bloc.
Shutdown Politics: The U.S. government is on the verge of paralysis as lawmakers continue to play political brinkmanship with the nation’s finances.
- Congress has until Saturday to pass a bill to keep the government open. The House of Representatives has passed three appropriations bills that largely maintain defense-related expenditures. However, the House still has eight remaining appropriations bills to pass to keep the government fully funded. The political standoff in Congress, which is split in both houses, is making it difficult to reach an agreement. Grandstanding from members of the GOP Freedom Caucus, in particular, is hindering progress. The Senate has already passed a short-term spending bill, but the House is not expected to call it to a vote. The standoff may not last longer than a week, but it is unclear what is needed to get the ball rolling.
- The row over government debt continues to unnerve investors, highlighting government dysfunction. Moody’s, the last of the big three credit rating agencies to give the U.S. its highest rank, has warned that the wrangling could jeopardize its stance on U.S. government debt. At the same time, Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has warned that a delay in releasing data could complicate policymakers’ ability to judge the economy’s state, especially the heavily watched job employment numbers, which could lead to market volatility.

- Legislative gridlock is likely to persist over the next few years, as neither Republicans nor Democrats have been able to create a unified message for the country. This growing partisanship suggests that neither side will be able to make major changes to the economic system without the help of the court system, which typically favors conservatives. Therefore, it is unlikely that the government will be able to reach a long-term resolution on its burgeoning debt burden. While this may make investors less likely to hold U.S. Treasury securities, we do not believe that these concerns will outweigh other issues, such as inflation and economic growth.
Business Cycle Report (September 28, 2023)
by Thomas Wash | PDF
The business cycle has a major impact on financial markets; recessions usually accompany bear markets in equities. The intention of this report is to keep our readers apprised of the potential for recession, updated on a monthly basis. Although it isn’t the final word on our views about recession, it is part of our process in signaling the potential for a downturn.
The Confluence Diffusion Index declined for the first time in seven months in a sign that the economy is still not in the clear. The August report showed that seven out of 11 benchmarks are in contraction territory. Last month, the diffusion index declined from -0.1515 to -0.3333, below the recovery signal of -0.1000.
- Equities are losing steam due to concerns about monetary policy.
- Consumer sentiment is improving but confidence remains low.
- Despite a slowdown in hiring, the labor market remains tight.

The chart above shows the Confluence Diffusion Index. It uses a three-month moving average of 11 leading indicators to track the state of the business cycle. The red line signals when the business cycle is headed toward a contraction, while the blue line signals when the business cycle is in recovery. The diffusion index currently provides about six months of lead time for a contraction and five months of lead time for recovery. Continue reading for an in-depth understanding of how the indicators are performing. At the end of the report, the Glossary of Charts describes each chart and its measures. In addition, a chart title listed in red indicates that the index is signaling recession.
Daily Comment (September 28, 2023)
by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash
[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF
Good morning! The S&P 500 is off to a decent start, 10-year Treasury yields are up, and Republican contenders failed to make a spark at last night’s debate. Today’s Comment will cover the rising dollar, several unions’ fights against AI, and Russia’s waning influence over neighboring regions.
Fed Lifting the Dollar: The U.S. dollar has hit a 10-month high against its peers as investors accept the Fed’s “restrictive for longer” narrative.
- Bolstered by stronger-than-expected economic growth and hawkish monetary policy from the Federal Reserve, the dollar index is poised for its eleventh consecutive week of gains, outperforming its G-10 peers. Meanwhile, Fed policymakers have shown a greater willingness to tighten policy than their counterparts at the ECB and BOJ who have both maintained a preference for keeping rates at their current levels at least for the rest of 2023. Earlier this month, Fed Governor Michelle Bowman and Boston Fed President Susan Collins called for further tightening to address rising inflation. However, Minneapolis Fed President Neel Kashkari has cautioned that economic disruptions, such as a government shutdown or union strikes, could lead FOMC members to hold off on another rate increase.
- The USD is likely to remain strong in the near term due to expectations of higher interest rates and faster economic growth in the U.S. than in other major economies. Interest rate swaps suggest that U.S. policy rates will rise faster than most other advanced economies in the coming three months. At the same time, GDP growth is expected to accelerate in the U.S. from an annual rate of 2.2% to 4.9% in the third quarter. In contrast, nowcasts show that the eurozone economy will contract an annualized 0.9% from July to September, and Canada’s economy will expand by a scant annual rate of 1.2% in the same period.

- Despite its current strength, the dollar is likely to face some headwinds in 2024. This is because Fed officials expect to cut interest rates at least once next year, while other central banks may keep rates steady or even tighten. As this chart above shows, U.S. policy rates generally rise and fall faster when compared to other advanced economies. The divergence in monetary policy could lead to a period in which other currencies start to gain on the dollar. This may make foreign stocks more attractive, especially as countries start to exit the trough phase of the business cycle.
Unions Against AI: The new labor contract for screenwriters may provide a roadmap of how labor unions can protect themselves against AI.
- Hollywood screenwriters have ended their five-month strike against studios and are expected to return to work this week. Under the new agreement, studios are required to disclose whether material given to them has been sourced from AI, either partially or in full. AI cannot receive a writer’s credit, and AI cannot be used to rewrite scripts. These new rules are the first time that guardrails have been established for this burgeoning technology, and similar agreements are expected to follow. Not long after the agreement, Hollywood video game actors announced their own strike, seeking further limits on AI.
- The movement to combat the threat of AI is likely to spread to other industries, as workers across the globe become concerned about its potential to displace them. A recent study from Goldman Sachs suggests that over 300 million jobs may be at risk, and a Pew Research study found that 27% of jobs that require a bachelor’s degrees may also be vulnerable. This rising fear has led to increased political scrutiny, as governments seek to understand and mitigate the potentially negative impacts of AI. In order to alleviate concerns, President Biden is expected to release an executive order on AI in the coming weeks.

(Source: Pew Research Center)
- Despite its growing significance, the labor struggles against AI have, so far, flown under the radar. During Wednesday’s Republican debate, there were few references to the new technology. This is likely to change during the election season, as candidates will be forced to discuss how they plan to mitigate the impact of AI on the job market, while still incentivizing firms to innovate as the U.S. looks to maintain its lead on China in that area. Although AI is likely to offer a lot of productivity gains and make firms more profitable, regulatory uncertainty still makes investment in the space relatively difficult, especially at current valuations.
Russia’s Waning Influence: An ally of Moscow was forced to cede territory to a rival after a tumultuous conflict.
- The self-governing Nagorno-Karabakh, an Armenian enclave within a territory internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan, surrendered to Azerbaijan following a military clash last week, and announced it will dissolve on January 1, 2024. Many Armenian residents were allowed to leave, but some were forced to stay, including billionaire Ruben Vardanyan, who has close ties to the Kremlin. The region, which many believed was under Russian protection, now faces accusations of ethnic cleansing, as locals fear retaliation from their Azerbaijani captors. This situation reflects Russia’s inability to enforce the ceasefire that it brokered with Azerbaijan in 2020.
- Russia’s reluctance to get involved in conflicts outside of Ukraine may be due to budget constraints. As a result of Western isolation and sanctions, the Kremlin has had trouble funding its expenditures and has been working to reduce its debt burden. The government has been able to lower its debt by around $128 billion since the start of the war, as it adapts to a changing environment. The recent rebound in oil prices has offered the country some relief, but domestic shortages have forced the country to ban exports of certain fuels.

- Russia’s waning influence in the Caucasus and Central Asia could create a power vacuum that could be exploited by other actors and potentially lead to increased conflict. Countries such as Georgia and Kazakhstan are likely vulnerable to heightened tensions given the lack of a Russian counterweight. At this time, it appear that China and the U.S. are looking to fill the void left by Moscow, but it isn’t clear whether either side can offer the same level of security commitments. An outbreak of violence, particularly in the countries surrounding the Caspian Sea, could further exacerbate commodity uncertainty and drive up oil prices, as the region supplies over 20% of global oil and 26% of global gas supplies. Investors should pay close attention to tensions in this part of the world.
Other stories that made us think:
- Why Hasn’t the Gold Price Fallen Further?– Bloomberg
- Oil Prices Are Rising. Shale Isn’t Coming to the Rescue– Wall Street Journal
- Rising headwinds threaten US economy’s resilience– Financial Times
Weekly Energy Update (September 28, 2023)
by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF
Oil prices are breaking out, raising the potential for a move toward $95 per barrel.
(Source: Barchart.com)
Commercial crude oil inventories fell 2.2 mb compared to forecasts of a 2.0 mb build. The SPR fell 0.3 mb, which puts the net draw at 2.4 mb (difference due to rounding).

In the details, U.S. crude oil production was steady at 12.9 mbpd. Exports fell 1.1 mbpd, while imports rose 0.7 mbpd. Refining activity fell 1.6% to 89.5% of capacity. We are clearly heading into the autumn refinery maintenance period which should reduce demand.
(Sources: DOE, CIM)
(Sources: DOE, CIM)
The above chart shows the seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories. Last week’s decline is contra seasonal and thus is bullish for crude oil prices.

Fair value, using commercial inventories and the EUR for independent variables, yields a price of $74.92. Commercial inventory levels are a bearish factor for oil prices, but with the unprecedented withdrawal of SPR oil, we think that the total-stocks number is more relevant.
Since the SPR is being used, to some extent, as a buffer stock, we have constructed oil inventory charts incorporating both the SPR and commercial inventories.

Total stockpiles peaked in 2017 and are now at levels last seen in late 1984. Using total stocks since 2015, fair value is $95.49.
Market News:
- The IEA issued an updated report detailing what would be necessary to reach carbon reduction goals by 2030. Generally speaking, it is still possible to reach these goals, but the path is narrowing. The IEA claims that fossil fuel demand will need to decline 25% by 2030; we suspect that isn’t likely.
- Oil execs claim that without more support for shale drilling, oil is headed to $150 per barrel. We don’t think that is probable in the near future because OPEC+ has significant excess capacity. However, over time, it could occur. The idea that demand must fall by 25% will likely temper investment activity in oil and gas.
- One of the key factors in shale production is water. There are concerns that Texas is consuming so much water that it may eventually curtail output.
- U.S. oil production is steadily rising and is offsetting some of the production cuts from OPEC+.
- As oil prices continue to rise, the G-7 cap on Russian oil prices has become irrelevant. The restrictions on Western insurance remain in place but are increasingly being ignored as Russia is managing to acquire insurance from other sources.
- Russia has banned product sales in a bid to ensure ample domestic supplies. Russian domestic prices have declined in the wake of the restrictions.
- Although there is still talk about phasing out fossil fuels in the West, China’s climate envoy has made it clear that Beijing isn’t ready to give up on these fuels anytime soon. This comment makes the idea of “peak oil demand” appear a bit premature.
- It was a warm summer, and September has also been warm. The combination of undersea volcanic activity, the emerging El Niño, and the peak of the solar cycle have all combined to lift summer temperatures. We will now be watching to see if we have a mild winter as a continuation of these trends.
- Russia banned the export of distillate products earlier this month, but as prices have increased, it has lifted its ban on bunker fuel, the high-sulfur fuel usually burned by ships.
- Despite high prices, U.S. E&P company capex remains constrained.
Geopolitical News:
- In the wake of the Iran/U.S. prisoner swap, there is hope that the two parties will use this event to improve relations. Although we have our doubts that this will work, there are parties trying to foster negotiations.
- Qatar is offering to facilitate talks between the U.S. and Iran about moving forward on a new nuclear deal.
- On the other hand, Iran’s foreign minister, who was in New York for the UN General Assembly meetings, was unable to visit Washington for talks.
- Robert Malley, who we discussed in an earlier Weekly Energy Update, appears to be part of a deep influence campaign by Iran.
- President Raisi of Iran is calling for the U.S. to leave the Middle East.
- Iran claims to have thwarted a massive bombing campaign. Tehran blames Israel.
- In a bid to conserve foreign currency reserves, Iraq will restrict all internal transactions to the IQD. Usually when a central bank puts such restrictions in place, the action reduces trade.
- Over the past few weeks, we have discussed Saudi/Israeli normalization. The barriers to a deal remain high, but talks appear to be continuing. As a potential deal looms, Iran is trying to figure out how to respond. A KSA/U.S./Israel deal would create a formidable obstacle to Iran’s goal of dominating the region.
- As negotiations continue, we note that the new Saudi envoy to the Palestinians has visited the West Bank. Also, Israel’s tourism minister has visited the KSA, which makes the minister the highest ranking official to actually visit Saudi Arabia.
- One of the key elements of the geopolitics of oil is that Europe lacks enough oil and natural gas to be energy independent. Thus, it needs imports to meet its energy needs. The U.S. wants Europe to be dependent on America. Europe, obviously, wants diversity of sources. Washington has historically tolerated Europe getting supplies from the Middle East and Africa but has consistently opposed Europe getting oil and gas from Russia. As the war in Ukraine has disrupted Russian supplies, the EU is finding itself increasingly dependent on the U.S., especially for natural gas.
- Mexico is planning to join the ranks of LNG export nations.
- Chevron (CVX, $170.23) announced it will resume drilling activity in Venezuela. The country has been under sanction for some time, but in the wake of the war in Ukraine, Washington has gradually lifted sanctions in a bid to keep oil prices under control.
- At the same time, Citgo, the large U.S. refiner that is a subsidiary of the Venezuelan state oil company PDVSA, will be auctioned off to pay Venezuelan debt. So far, the Maduro government hasn’t taken measures to stop the sale.
Alternative Energy/Policy News:
- European officials warn that the region must diversify its solar panel supply chains away from its dependence on China. The U.S. industrial policy is attempting to support a domestic solar panel industry.
- The EU is getting increasingly aggressive in protecting its auto industry, threatening not only China but also U.S. EV producers with trade restrictions.
- China is also dominant in rare earths mining and processing. Vietnam is vying to compete with China in this market.
- Vietnam is also making headway in the EV market and hopes to become a source for the EU now that Europe is considering restricting Chinese EVs.
- Ford (F, $12.55) halted work on a battery plant in Michigan. The plant, which uses Chinese licensed technology, has been controversial. The UAW, which is currently striking, has claimed that this halt was designed to influence the union’s wage efforts. However, the company claims it isn’t sure it can “competitively” operate the plant.
- Chinese firms are investing in Moroccan phosphate, which they use in batteries.
- Looking for a good primer on EV batteries? This report from The Economist lays out the different battery technologies and where new developments are going.
- Geothermal energy remains an attractive alternative energy. So far, it has mostly been restricted to regions with volcanic activity but there are hopes that it can be deployed more broadly. In addition, there is research under way to make current geothermal power more efficient.
- There is also research in progress that could transform CO2 into synthetic natural gas.
- The U.S. is aiming to build a nuclear fusion facility within the next decade.
- Microsoft (MSFT, $310.65) is funding small modular reactors to provide energy to the company. This energy is designed to, in part, provide electricity for its AI efforts.
Daily Comment (September 27, 2023)
by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash
[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF
Our Comment today opens with the latest on the prospects for a partial shutdown of the U.S. government starting this weekend due to budget gridlock. We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including an improvement in British Prime Minister Sunak’s approval ratings after he eased the U.K.’s climate-stabilization policies and a few words on U.S. antitrust policy.
U.S. Government Shutdown: The Senate last night advanced a bipartisan stopgap spending bill that would keep the federal government funded at today’s levels from the expiration of the current fiscal year on Saturday until November 17. The bill is designed to give Democrats and Republicans more time to negotiate and pass the needed full-year appropriations bills.
- However, Republicans in the House said they wouldn’t consider the Senate’s bill.
- Instead, they voted to clear the way for debate on just four of the 12 appropriations bills, i.e., those for the Departments of Defense, Homeland Security, Agriculture, and State.
- While setting up debate on the four spending bills is a win for House Speaker McCarthy, final passage of the four bills before fiscal year-end on Saturday would still leave the departments that rely on the remaining eight bills unfunded.
- Since those departments are often top budget-cutting targets, many right-wing Republicans would probably try to drive a very hard bargain before passing their funding bills.
- Their approach could well include refusing to pass a stopgap spending bill, setting the stage for a partial government shutdown.
China-Philippines-United States: After China installed floating barriers to keep Philippine fishing boats out of a contested shoal in the South China Sea, as we reported in our Comment on Monday, the Philippines has taken the risky step of removing the barrier and now plans to step up military, coast guard, and administrative patrols of the area. It is still not clear how Beijing will respond to Manila’s new self-assertiveness, but because of the U.S.-Philippines mutual defense treaty, the action probably raises the risk of increased tension or conflict between the U.S. and China.
China-Australia: Although bilateral relations have improved under Australian Prime Minister Albanese, with China lifting its punitive import restrictions on Australian coal and barley, the country is still struggling with Chinese punitive import tariffs on Australian wine. New data shows Australia now has about two billion liters of excess wine in storage, equal to about 859 Olympic-sized swimming pools. Albanese reportedly urged the end of wine restrictions when he met with Chinese Premier Li Qiang this month, but in the meantime, the glut of supply suggests there may be some good bargains on Australian Shiraz, Cabernet Sauvignon, or other varietals in your local supermarket.
China: The government’s China Integrated Circuit Investment Fund, known as the “Big Fund,” is reportedly having trouble raising new money from its target investor base of state-owned enterprises and local governments. The fund, which has been instrumental in developing China’s semiconductor industry since it was established in 2014, raised the equivalent of about $20 billion and $28 billion in its first two funding rounds, but it is falling short of its goal to raise an additional $41 billion in the current round.
- The shortfall in funding reflects China’s sharp slowdown in economic growth and the increased debt loads faced by state-owned firms and local governments. The country’s finance ministry could step in to make up the shortfall but appears reluctant to do so.
- The funding shortfall not only could temper the further development of China’s technology industry, but it also illustrates the potential that sluggish economic growth and high debt have to slow China’s military buildup over time.
- On the other hand, if President Xi senses that a prolonged growth slowdown and debt burden will limit future military investments, he could potentially be tempted to launch his long-desired takeover of Taiwan earlier rather than later.

United Kingdom Politics: Following Prime Minister Sunak’s decision last week to delay or jettison some of the government’s climate-stabilization regulations, a new poll suggests that the move will be a political winner. According to the poll, public approval for Sunak’s Conservative Party has risen by eight percentage points since the announcement, cutting the Labor Party’s lead to 16 percentage points from 24 previously. The results suggest governments in Europe may continue to water down their green-energy policies as households begin to push back against their costs and inconveniences.
United Kingdom Regulatory Policy: The Financial Conduct Authority, the U.K.’s top financial regulator, said it will open an investigation into asset valuations in private markets. The probe reflects growing concerns in the U.K. and elsewhere that valuations on private assets are often overly rosy, potentially setting up financial volatility in time of crisis or falling valuations.
Greece: The right-wing government of Prime Minister Mitsotakis yesterday said it will grant legal status to as many as 300,000 illegal immigrants to help ease the country’s labor shortages in agriculture, tourism, and construction. Similar to the scandal in which Poland’s right-wing, anti-immigrant government was discovered to be selling immigration visas, the new policy in Greece illustrates the tension between conservative governments’ rhetoric against immigration and the opportunity for immigrants to ease labor shortages in the developed world.
U.S. Antitrust Policy: Yesterday, the Federal Trade Commission and 17 states filed a long-expected antitrust complaint against Amazon (AMZN, $125.98), alleging the online retailer illegally wields monopoly power that harms its competitors and keeps prices artificially high. Nevertheless, FTC Chairwoman Khan has had a spotty record with her antitrust suits, so it isn’t clear at this point whether the company would really be convicted and forced to change its operations.
U.S. Labor Market: The Writers Guild of America said its members can go back to work today under the union’s tentative new labor contract with the major movie studios, streamers, and television networks. However, members won’t vote to give formal approval of the new contract until a poll that will run from October 2 to October 9.
- According to the WGA, its initial proposal in the negotiations would have had a value of $429 million annually, while the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers made an initial offer worth just $86 million per year.
- The WGA estimates that the tentative deal will be worth $233 million per year. That’s just 54% of its initial ask, but it’s 2.7x what the employers initially offered.
Daily Comment (September 26, 2023)
by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash
[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF
Our Comment today opens with a new report from the International Energy Agency that could further discourage needed investments in fossil fuel supplies and could help drive energy prices even higher in the coming years. We then review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including additional confirmation that the European Union intends to clamp down on its trade with China and signs of preparations for a partial shutdown of the U.S. government which could begin on Saturday.
Global Climate Change Policy: The International Energy Agency has issued a new report estimating that global use of fossil fuels would have to fall 25% by 2030 in order for nations to meet their goal of net-zero greenhouse gas emissions and realize their hopes of limiting global temperature increases. The report comes amid intensifying pushback against the IEA from the world’s oil and natural gas industry, which is accusing the agency of being too alarmist and too reckless in discouraging the fossil energy investments needed to fuel the world until greener technologies are ready for wider use. We have also noted that many governments around the world, especially in Europe, have started to step back from their most aggressive climate-stabilization policies amid pushback from voters.
- While the report also called for faster deployment of green energy technologies, it warned they may not be ready soon enough. Therefore, “Prolonged high prices would result if the decline in fossil fuel investment in this scenario were to precede the expansion of clean energy.” In the IEA’s view, an orderly transition is “far from guaranteed.”
- Coupled with potential supply disruptions associated with the U.S.-China geopolitical rivalry, we think the regulatory and financial-market headwinds against fossil-fuel exploration and development will likely crimp supplies going forward. That’s a key reason why we think mineral commodities will be in a prolonged bull market in the coming years, once we get past the soft growth or recession that seems likely in the near term.
Saudi Arabia: Energy Minister Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman told the annual conference of the International Atomic Energy Agency that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia will adopt a strict “Comprehensive Safeguards Agreement” with the agency that will allow IAEA inspectors to monitor Saudi nuclear activities. The move provides more evidence that Saudi Arabia is pushing hard to win a U.S.-run nuclear processing facility as part of its price for normalizing relations with Israel. Besides the nuclear processing facility, the Saudis are also seeking security guarantees from the U.S.
- Saudi-U.S.-Israeli negotiations toward normalization are continuing.
- In the meantime, it is increasingly clear that the Saudis are holding down crude oil production to boost global energy prices and heap additional pressure on President Biden for concessions.
- Along with the recent dearth in new fossil fuel development, the cut in production by Saudi Arabia and its allies continues to boost global oil prices. So far this morning, Brent crude is trading down 0.7% at $91.29 per barrel, but that’s still up dramatically from only about $71.75 in early summer.
- The rise in energy prices has also increased worries that consumer price inflation will prove stickier than earlier thought, prompting the Fed to keep interest rates higher for longer. As a result, the yield on the benchmark 10-year Treasury note closed yesterday at a multi-year high of 4.541%.
European Union-China: During a speech in Beijing, EU Trade Commissioner Dombrovskis warned yesterday that China’s “lack of reciprocity and a level playing field [in trade], coupled with wider geopolitical shifts, has [sic] forced Europe to become more assertive.” Coming so soon after EU Commission President von der Leyen’s recent announcement of an anti-subsidy probe into Chinese electric vehicle exports, and shortly before Dombrovskis was scheduled to meet Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng, the trade commissioner’s statement helped confirm that the EU has swung around to a more protectionist stance regarding trade and investment with China.
- Dombrovskis also warned today that the EU’s anti-subsidy investigation would include vehicles made by Western companies in China.
- Although Chinese-made EVs currently account for only a modest share of European sales, their rapidly advancing quality and lower costs are expected to help them capture a huge amount of market share in the coming years.
- Almost all of the Chinese-made EVs currently sold in Europe are from Chinese-owned European brands such as Britain’s MG, owned by China’s SAIC (600104.SS, CNY, 14.86), or from joint ventures between European and Chinese companies.
South Korea: Lee Bok-hyun, governor of the Financial Supervisory Service, said he thinks South Korea has now met most of the conditions to be included in the FTSE Russell World Government Bond Index. The index managers are expected to meet soon to decide on any changes in index constituents. If they decide to include South Korea, the country is expected to account for up to 2.5% of the index, which would likely translate into around $65 billion of additional purchases of the country’s government bonds.
United States-South Pacific Islands: President Biden yesterday hosted the leaders of 16 different South Pacific nations at the White House as part of an effort to keep them from falling for China’s recent diplomatic, military, and economic overtures. At the meeting, Biden announced several new embassies and aid programs for the region. However, Solomon Islands Prime Minister Sogavare failed to show up for the meeting, illustrating his increasing alignment with Beijing.
U.S. Government Shutdown: Some lawmakers are reportedly working on an emergency bill to protect active-duty troops from losing their pay in the event of a partial government shutdown which could start on Saturday. As during the shutdown of October 2013, the legislation would aim to protect troop morale and avoid imposing financial difficulties on military families. However, unlike the legislation in 2013, this bill would also apply to members of the Coast Guard.
- Even if troop pay is protected, more than half of the Defense Department’s large civilian workforce would likely be furloughed.
- That illustrates how the economy could face a large hit to demand in the event of a partial shutdown. In addition, Moody’s (MCO, $322.81), the last major credit assessment firm with a AAA rating on Treasury debt, warned yesterday that it would consider a shutdown to be “credit negative” for U.S. obligations.
- As we argued in our Comment yesterday, a shutdown could potentially have a big impact on today’s “slow bicycle economy,” which has likely lost enough momentum to become more susceptible to recession even if there is only a modest hit to demand or confidence.
U.S. Electrical Vehicle Industry: Ford Motor (F, $12.58) announced it will pause construction of a controversial factory in Dearborn, Michigan, where it planned to make electric vehicle batteries using technology from Chinese green-tech giant Contemporary Amperex Technology, or CATL (300750.SZ, CNY, 206.27). Ford said the pause was caused in part by the on-going United Auto Workers’ strike, but it also cited unspecified other issues. That could mean the company has gotten cold feet after being criticized for relying on Chinese technology and seeing how many governments around the world are stepping back from their climate-change regulations.
- Regarding the strike, today both President Biden and Former President Trump will visit the UAW picket lines in Michigan to show their support for the workers. Biden’s visit will mark the first time a sitting president has ever joined the strikers on a picket line.
- Of course, the visits by such high-stature politicians are likely to further encourage the strikers. Despite the UAW being happy with some recent concessions by Ford in the negotiations, it doesn’t look like the work stoppage will end anytime soon.

