Daily Comment (March 24, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! Today’s report will continue with our focus on the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Afterward, we discuss non-Ukraine-related news and close with our pandemic coverage.

President Biden plans to meet with NATO and EU leaders on Thursday to discuss imposing tougher sanctions on Russia. The new sanctions are expected to be more targeted but will likely not result in the banning of Russian oil and gas in Europe. The push to tighten sanctions comes amid growing speculation that Russia will look to use nuclear or chemical weapons in Ukraine.  NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg has stated that using such weapons would likely signal an escalation of the conflict, but he failed to call it a red line. On Wednesday, NATO countries sent additional resources to Ukraine to help defend itself from such an attack.

From our perspective, the use of nuclear weapons by Russia likely carries more risk than the country is willing to bear. As mentioned in a previous report, Chinese President Xi Jinping signed a pledge to protect Ukraine from a nuclear attack; thus, Beijing may be forced to respond to Russia if such weapons are used in the conflict. How China may respond is unclear because the pledge does not go beyond an agreement to defend Ukraine. However, it will most likely come in the form of a reduction in sanctions relief for Russia. Note that China has publicly come out in support of Russia by spreading many of the talking points promoted by the Kremlin. There isn’t much evidence that China has tried to evade the sanctions, suggesting that Beijing is still not ready to put all of its eggs into one basket by supporting Russia.  There is even some speculation that China may be trying to distance itself from Russia as the conflict with Ukraine escalates. That being said, the lack of support from China does not mean that there is no possibility of a nuclear or chemical attack from Russia but suggests the costs would likely exceed the benefits. As a result, we suspect the uncertainty in markets because of the Russian invasion will likely persist for the foreseeable future as there doesn’t appear to be an off-ramp for either Russia or Ukraine at this point.

  • In other news, Russian President Vladimir Putin has asked countries to pay for their oil and gas using rubles. The move comes as the country continues to struggle to deal with the economic ramifications of the sanctions. An article from the WSJ details the impact of sanctions on Russia’s oil and gas industry despite the fact that Russian energy companies, for the most part, have not been targeted. Although in the short run, the demand for rubles will lead to an appreciation of the currency against the dollar. The sudden change in form of payment is almost certainly a breach of contract and will most likely be challenged in court. So far, Putin has given no indication that he is preparing to cut Europe off. However, this suggests Russia is considering weaning itself off Western currencies in general as it positions itself toward autarky. Putin’s announcement has led to an increase in commodity prices and the ruble.
    • The Russian stock market partially reopened on Thursday after being closed for a month following the country’s invasion of Ukraine.  On its opening, the stock market rose as high as 12 percent before paring back much of its gains. The rise should not come as a surprise, as western investors, who own up to 80% of the free-floating market, were prevented from selling. Additionally, short selling was banned. The move comes as Russia attempts to rebuild trust in its equity markets and avert a financial crisis. To support its stock market, the Kremlin plans to inject over one trillion rubles ($10.3 billion) into the market from the country’s National Wealth Fund.
  • In Ukraine, officials announced it struck a Russian-occupied port facility, suggesting the country is still finding some success in holding off Russian forces. The port was an important logistic hub for Russian forces, and the act provides further evidence the war is not close to ending.
  • The Biden administration is expected to ask for $813.3 billion in national security spending in the federal budget for the next fiscal year.

Non-Ukraine news:

COVID-19: The number of reported cases is 475,935,572, with 6,105,530 fatalities.  In the U.S., there are 79,844,751 confirmed cases with 974,833 deaths. For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics. The CDC reports that 699,566,225 doses of the vaccine have been distributed, with 558,918,245 doses injected. The number receiving at least one dose is 255,001,325, while the number of second doses is 217,184,868, and the number of the third dose, granting the highest level of immunity, is 96,874,549. The FT has a page on global vaccine distribution.

View PDF

Weekly Energy Update (March 24, 2022)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

After falling last week, oil prices have moved steadily higher on continued tensions in Ukraine.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Crude oil inventories fell 2.5 mb compared to a 0.5 mb draw forecast.  The SPR declined 4.2 mb, meaning the net draw was 6.7 mb.  The withdrawal from the SPR was near the surge maximum of 4.4 mbpd, which suggests the government is moving aggressively to lower oil prices.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production was unchanged at 11.6 mbpd.  Exports rose 0.9 mbpd, while imports rose 0.1 mb.  Refining activity rose 0.7% and is now 91.1% of capacity.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

This chart shows the seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  We are seeing inventories continue to diverge from the usual seasonal pattern.

These charts make evident that the normal relationships between the dollar, inventory, and oil prices are currently broken.  However, the chart on the left indicates the degree of overvaluation has narrowed.  The first report after the war started is represented by the circle; we have seen prices move in (the average daily price during the month of March is used for this dot).  Overall, the market is consolidating after the major war spike.  We look for continued consolidation, although we note that the situation with Ukraine remains fluid, and prices could move strongly in either direction on war news.

 Market news:

But not all of this gas will go to Europe unless pricing supports those flows.  Recent pricing has been supportive of flows going to Europe, but that may change if Asia also tries to lift inventories.  The U.S. has relaxed some trading rules recently that may help lift LNG exports to the EU.  But, there is one problem looming in this scenario; it appears we will have a “back-to-back” la Niña, which raises the chances for extended drought and a hotter-than-normal summer.  The last time this sort of event occurred was in 2012.  The summer of that year, for the region east of the Rockies, was quite hot.  July of that year was the second hottest on record in terms of population-weighted degree days, and June was the 12th hottest.  If the U.S. has a hot summer, it may not be possible for America to boost LNG supplies to Europe.

 Geopolitical news:

  Alternative energy/policy news:

  View PDF

Daily Comment (March 23, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Once again, our Comment opens with an update on the Russia-Ukraine war, where the leading news over the next couple of days is likely to be the major allied diplomatic meetings in Europe.  We next review a range of international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today.  We conclude with the latest news on the coronavirus pandemic.

Russia-Ukraine:  Russian invasion forces remain essentially stalled in northern and eastern Ukraine, while the Ukrainian defenders are reportedly mounting modest counterattacks in an effort to push them back or at least disrupt their ongoing resupply efforts.  The Russians appear to be making some progress in consolidating their hold on the country’s southeastern coastline, but vicious street fighting continues in the city of Mariupol.  According to U.S. defense officials, more than 10% of Russia’s invasion troops have been killed or wounded and are no longer in the fight.  To make up for those losses and regain momentum, Russian President Putin appears to be pressuring Belarusian President Lukashenka to throw his troops into the battle.  However, Ukrainian military officials say Lukashenka and the Belarusian military strongly resist that idea, at least for the time being.

Taiwan:  As Taipei continues to consider the lessons of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, officials say they may extend compulsory military service beyond the current four months.  Taiwan has been gradually shifting from a conscript military to a volunteer-dominated professional force, but Beijing’s growing pressure against the island it claims as its own, as well as Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, have prompted debate about how to boost civil defense.

United Kingdom:  The February Consumer Price Index was up 6.2% year-over-year, accelerating from the January gain of 5.5% and marking the highest inflation rate since 1992 (see chart immediately below, and the data tables farther down).  The figures illustrate how the current inflation problem is widespread around the world.  The figures also suggest the Bank of England will face pressure to hike interest rates further in the coming months.

United States-United Kingdom:  The U.S. and the U.K. struck a trade accord under which the U.S. will allow the U.K. to ship “historically-based sustainable volumes” of steel and aluminum products to the U.S. without the levies imposed under the former Trump administration, while the U.K. will lift levies on American whiskey, motorcycles, and tobacco.

U.S. Monetary Policy:  Cleveland FRB President Loretta J. Mester yesterday said the Fed would have to raise interest rates many times as it seeks to lower very high levels of inflation.  According to Mester, the benchmark fed funds rate will have to reach 2.5% before the end of this year and even higher in 2023.

  • Mester’s year-end target of 2.5% is a bit lower than several other policymakers have suggested, but it still underscores the extent to which the monetary officials are panicked by inflation and are now intent on ratcheting up interest rates aggressively.
  • All the same, we continue to suspect their rate hikes will expose financial fragilities and/or an economic slowdown after even a limited number of increases, forcing the Fed to retreat.

Canada:  Prime Minister Trudeau and his center-left Liberal Party struck an agreement in which the leftist New Democratic Party will support his government in key votes until mid-2025.  The deal ensures that the Liberal government, which currently holds only a minority of seats in parliament, will be able to stay in power for at least the next three years.

  • Combined, the two parties hold a majority of the seats in parliament.
  • Under the agreement, the parties will cooperate in implementing a progressive agenda that focuses on climate change, expanding medical and dental coverage for lower-income Canadians, and delivering more affordable housing.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to  474,206,633 worldwide, with 6,099,561 deaths.  In the U.S., confirmed cases rose to 79,803,670, with 973,266 deaths.  (For an interactive chart that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population, click here.)  Meanwhile, in data on the U.S. vaccination program, the number of people who are considered fully vaccinated now totals 217,093,232, equal to 65.4% of the total population.

View PDF

Daily Comment (March 22, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

We begin today’s Comment with an update on the Russia-Ukraine war.  We next review a range of international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today.  We wrap up with the latest news on the coronavirus pandemic.

Russia-Ukraine:  The Russian and Ukrainian armed forces appear to remain in a stalemate over most of Ukraine, with both sides failing to gain much territory over the last day.  Russian troops entered the key southeastern port city of Mariupol, but fighting in the streets has apparently been indecisive.  In frustration over its inability to take more territory, the Russians continue to attack civilian areas with artillery, missiles, and aerial bombs.  U.S. officials say this might be a new strategy of wearing down the population so it will accede to Russian control of both Crimea and southeastern Ukraine.  Meanwhile, reports suggest railway workers in Belarus have been cooperating with Ukrainians to cut off railroad links between the countries and thwart Russia’s effort to resupply its troops in Ukraine.  Here in the U.S., yesterday, President Biden warned the nation’s businesses and nongovernmental organizations to immediately “harden” their defenses against potential cyberattacks by the Russian government, citing “evolving intelligence” of such plans by the Kremlin.  The President also warned again that Russia could use chemical weapons within Ukraine.

Belgium:  As Europe continues working to increase its energy security following the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Belgium’s federal government has postponed its plan to phase out nuclear electricity generation by 2025.  One reactor at both the Doel and Tihange nuclear power plants will have their lives extended by ten years to 2035.  The move further underscores our optimism regarding uranium and other aspects of the nuclear industry.

Japan:  Electric utilities are scrambling to keep the lights on in Tokyo today, as freezing temperatures and power plant outages following a strong earthquake last week put the nation’s capital at risk of blackouts.  The government has warned that households and businesses need to reduce power consumption as much as possible, although it is not yet clear how much that will weigh on overall Japanese economic activity or financial markets.

China:  Heavily indebted real estate development giant Evergrande (3333 HK, HKD, 1.65) said lenders to one of its property services units had seized $2.1 billion in cash pledged as security for third-party guarantees.  The move dealt a blow to international investors, hoping to recoup some of their losses through the subsidiary.  It will also put further downward pressure on Evergrande’s stock and bond values.

U.S. Monetary Policy:  During a moderated discussion after a speech in Washington yesterday, Federal Reserve Chair Powell warned that the central bank was prepared to raise interest rates in half-percentage-point steps and high enough to slow the economy deliberately, if needed, to bring down inflation.  The remarks struck a tougher tone than he used just days earlier in a press conference after the Fed voted to raise its benchmark rate by a quarter point.  In response, stock values fell yesterday, and bond yields have jumped.  Treasury obligations are now suffering through their worst month since late 2016.

U.S. Fiscal Policy:  Some state governments are also taking steps to mitigate the impact of high inflation, especially for energy products.  The steps include mostly short-term suspensions of state gasoline taxes, despite the loss of revenue that will mean for state coffers.

  • Maryland and Georgia have already suspended their state gasoline taxes.
  • Legislators in Illinois, Massachusetts, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, New York, and Tennessee are weighing whether to do the same.
  • Lawmakers in California are considering giving drivers a $400 rebate to help cushion the blow of high gasoline prices.

U.S. Regulatory Policy:  The SEC has proposed strict requirements for publicly traded companies to report information on greenhouse-gas emissions and risks related to climate change, in one of the Biden administration’s potentially most significant environmental actions to date.  The proposal will be open for public comment for at least two months before the agency begins work on a final rule.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to  472,222,374 worldwide, with 6,094,632 deaths.  In the U.S., confirmed cases rose to 79,778,973, with 972,634 deaths.  (For an interactive chart that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population, click here.)  Meanwhile, in data on the U.S. vaccination program, the number of people who are considered fully vaccinated now totals 217,093,232, equal to 65.4% of the total population.

  • In the U.S., the seven-day average of people hospitalized with a confirmed or suspected COVID-19 rose to 21,679 yesterday, although that was still down 41% from two weeks earlier.
  • In a sign of the continued decline of COVID-19 across the U.S., the Defense Department last Wednesday skipped its update of coronavirus case numbers—data it has faithfully published weekly since July 2021.
  • Even though China, Hong Kong, and some other Asian countries continue to grapple with their vast new Omicron waves, the situation continues to improve in Japan.  As of today, quasi-emergency measures have ended in all 18 prefectures they had covered, including Tokyo and Osaka, amid a decreasing trend in the number of new infections.  That marks the first time since January 8 that the country has no emergency measures in place.
  • A new study found that people who recovered from COVID-19 within the past year are 40% more likely to be diagnosed with diabetes compared to those who weren’t infected.  The increased risk translates into 1% of people who have had COVID-19 developing diabetes who otherwise wouldn’t have, resulting in potentially millions of new cases worldwide.

View PDF

Daily Comment (March 21, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with an update on the Russia-Ukraine war, where the Battle of Mariupol is intensifying.  We next review a range of international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today.  We wrap up with the latest news on the coronavirus pandemic.

Russia-Ukraine:  Even though the Russian invasion force has been fought to a standstill in most of Ukraine, it managed to break into the southeastern port city of Mariupol on Saturday.  The Russian military issued an ultimatum for the city’s defenders to surrender by 5:00 am local time today, but Ukraine has rejected it.  The latest reports indicate there is currently fierce urban fighting in the city.  Meanwhile, on the diplomatic front, President Biden will hold a video conference today with the leaders of Germany, France, Italy, and Britain, before attending a NATO summit in Brussels on Wednesday, participating in a European Council summit on Thursday, and traveling to Poland on Friday.

  • If the Russians take control of Mariupol, it will probably free up forces that could be used to reinvigorate their attacks elsewhere in Ukraine.  For the time being, however, the intense urban warfare in Mariupol will likely absorb and destroy massive amounts of Russian manpower, weaponry, and morale.
  • The Russian invasion force continues to suffer immense casualties, including high-ranking officers.  The deputy commander of Russia’s Black Sea Fleet was killed near Mariupol over the weekend, bringing the number of top-ranking officers killed in action in Ukraine to at least six.
  • Other reports indicate the Russians have forcibly deported thousands of Ukrainians from Mariupol to “filtration camps” in Russia and sent them elsewhere to work as slave laborers.
  • As we’ve been warning, skyrocketing grain prices because of the war have created food shortages and higher food prices in poorer countries, particularly in the Middle East.  Fertilizer prices are also soaring (see chart below).
  • One of the most potentially divisive issues at the meetings will be a Polish proposal to organize an international peacekeeping mission for Ukraine. While NATO has carried out such missions in Europe before, those were done after fighting eased.  President Biden has insisted that he won’t send U.S. troops into Ukraine because such a move would risk an all-out war between the U.S. and Russia.  However, increasing evidence of the Russian military’s weakness and poor operating capability could lead to more calls for intervention from those who advocate for such a move.  The Russian military’s continued poor performance also has the potential to push President Putin toward further escalation, perhaps to the point of using chemical or nuclear weapons in Ukraine.
    • Global investors appear to have become sanguine about the war in Ukraine in recent days, allowing financial markets to stabilize and even rebound.
    • However, it’s important to remember that military, economic, and financial risks still abound.

Germany-Qatar:  In a visit to Doha yesterday, German Economy Minister Robert Habeck reached an agreement with the Qatari government on a long-term natural gas supply deal to reduce Germany’s reliance on Russian gas in the wake of the Ukraine war.

United Kingdom:  In what could be another major move toward European energy security, Prime Minister Johnson will lay out a plan to boost Britain’s nuclear energy capacity by as much as fivefold by 2050.  The plan would imply the construction of at least half a dozen big new stations over the next 25 years.  Coupled with other European countries’ new focus on energy independence, Johnson’s plan underscores our optimism toward uranium and other aspects of the nuclear industry.

China:  The Hong Kong stock market has suspended trading in the shares of highly indebted property developer Evergrande (3333 HK, HKD,  1.65), pending a release of information from the company that could shed light on its restructuring and the fate of international investors.

U.S. Monetary Policy:  After dissenting to the Fed’s decision last week to hike its benchmark interest-rate target by 0.25%, in favor of a larger hike of 0.50%, St. Louis FRB President Bullard said on Friday that the Fed should boost rates all the way to 3.00% this year to avoid losing credibility regarding its commitment to fighting inflation.  In contrast, the Fed policymakers’ economic projects released at last week’s meeting called for hiking the benchmark rate to about 1.90% by the end of 2022.

  • Bullard’s statement underscores the extent to which some Fed policymakers want to raise interest rates to combat inflation.
  • As we’ve noted before, however, we suspect that slowing economic growth and financial fragilities will keep the Fed from hiking rates more than a few times this year.

United States-Saudi Arabia:  In an apparent effort by President Biden to spur cooperation in bringing down energy prices, his administration has transferred a significant number of Patriot antimissile interceptors to Saudi Arabia, fulfilling Riyadh’s urgent request for resupply to fend off drone and missile attacks by Iran-backed Houthi rebels in neighboring Yemen.

U.S. Energy Industry:  Amid high energy prices sparked by rebounding demand and supply concerns related to the Russia-Ukraine war, the number of active U.S. oil rigs has grown by roughly one-fifth in the past six months.  However, much of the new activity is to make up for a depleted inventory of wells drilled before the pandemic and isn’t expected to increase overall output enough to bring down prices significantly.

U.S. Ports:  As we’ve been warning, the tight labor market and this summer’s expiration of the West Coast longshoremen’s labor contract raises the prospect of a strike that would further disrupt supply chains and boost inflation.  To avoid the potential disruptions, some shippers are reportedly pulling forward their holiday-season orders to get them into domestic networks early, and many are diverting cargo that normally moves through the West Coast to East Coast and Gulf Coast ports.

Global Semiconductor Industry:  Even as the Fed and other central banks try to bring down inflation, the Russia-Ukraine war and other supply shocks promise to keep prices high.  The latest bad news on that front comes from ASML (ASML, USD, 679.86), the Dutch maker of lithography machines needed to produce the most advanced chips.  According to CEO Peter Wennink, it will be another two years before the company can produce all the chipmaking machines required by semiconductor firms to meet their customers’ demands.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to  470,852,725 worldwide, with 6,078,361 deaths.  In the U.S., confirmed cases rose to 79,734,867, with 971,162 deaths.  (For an interactive chart that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population, click here.)  Meanwhile, in data on the U.S. vaccination program, the number of people who are considered fully vaccinated now totals 217,060,180, equal to 65.4% of the total population.

View PDF

Asset Allocation Bi-Weekly – A Commodity Update (March 21, 2022)

by the Asset Allocation Committee | PDF

Since the beginning of the year, commodities, as measured by the Bloomberg Commodity Index, have been up 15.4%.  All other major asset classes are down for the year.  Among the S&P 500 sectors, only energy is positive.  Commodity prices were strong going into the war in Ukraine, but the incursion coupled with the subsequent sanctions have triggered a historic rally.  In this report, we put this rally in context and examine if it will continue.

In this chart, we deflate the CRB Index, starting in 1915, and regress the real index against a time trend.  The fact the green line declines over time shows why it is hard to be a commodity producer.  Over time, commodity prices adjusted for inflation tend to decline.  Market economies tend to use less “stuff” when making goods and services, meaning that the final product that a commodity producer makes doesn’t keep up with inflation.  However, as the deviation line on the chart shows, there are periods where commodity prices move well above trend.  The three spikes above-trend that occurred before 1970 were caused by war—WWI, WWII, and Korea.  The WWII spike was delayed until after the end of the war because of rationing and price controls.  The spike that lasted from 1973 to 1981 was partly due to the Vietnam War but was mostly a result of the monetary uncertainty triggered by Nixon’s decision to leave the Bretton Woods Agreement.  That bull market ended with the combination of the Reagan/Thatcher deregulation[1] and the Volcker’s interest rate shock in the early 1980s.  Since then, we have not had a major commodity bull market.  The one observed from 2000 to 2007 can be seen on the chart, but compared to earlier events, it was rather modest.

The above chart raises two questions.  First, will the war in Ukraine have an effect comparable to other major conflicts?  Second, if a commodity bull market is in the offing, will it look similar to those before 1981 or the one in 2000-07?  Let’s tackle the first question.  On its face, it seems unlikely that the war in Ukraine will become a resource-heavy industrialized conflict.  Although Moscow likely has designs on further expansion, an attack on a NATO nation could escalate to a superpower confrontation.  Thus, we expect Russia to use some degree of discretion before even considering expansion

However, even without a major mobilization similar to those of the pre-1980 wars, the impact on commodities could be similar.  There are two reasons.  First, Russia is a substantial commodity supplier, and the sanctions levied on Moscow have already disrupted commodity flows.  Without a quick resolution to the Ukraine War, these will likely stay in place indefinitely, and the longer they are in effect, the more consumers will adjust to higher prices.  Second, and even more concerning, are the financial sanctions effectively rendering most of Russia’s foreign reserves worthless.  Reserve managers worldwide must now account for the fact that if their nation becomes a target of the U.S., they could see similar treatment.  Thus, what assets are now reserve assets?  Again, as long as a nation has good relations with the U.S., it is probably safe to hold dollars and Treasuries.  But, if there is any chance of soured relations, the question of viable reserve assets becomes critical.  Russia found that euro assets proved to have the same problem as dollar assets, and even moving gold in quantity is difficult under sanction.  Reserve managers may conclude that the only assets that may have value in a crisis are commodities.  In other words, it would not surprise us to see nations start expanding stockpiles of commodities that would act as a buffer in a sanction crisis.

The answer to the second question probably rests on the behavior of central banks.  Part of the reason we saw commodity price spikes after WWII and during the Korean War was that the Federal Reserve was not independent.  During WWII, the Fed was forced to fix interest rates across the entire Treasury yield curve.  It led to a massive expansion of the Fed’s balance sheet.

Into WWII, the balance sheet rose to 22.9% of GDP and remained elevated into the early 1950s.  However, after the Fed’s independence in 1951, it gradually declined to around 6% of GDP…until the Great Financial Crisis.  The bouts of quantitative easing that occurred in the last decade led to a steady expansion of the balance sheet until quantitative tightening began in 2018.  That policy was abandoned in 2019 due to financial stress, and then quantitative easing resumed in earnest during the pandemic.  One could argue that the Federal Reserve accommodated the rise in commodity prices through its balance sheet practices in the 1940s into the early 1950s.  Given the vast expansion of the balance sheet since 2009, it is arguable that there is ample liquidity to accommodate another commodity bull market.

Finally, relative to GDP, the CRB Index remains undervalued.

The chart on the left shows the CRB Index, log-transformed, regressed against the level of nominal GDP.  Note that since around 2014, when oil prices fell, the CRB has been trading well below GDP.  In fact, the commodity market since 2014, relative to GDP, looks familiar to the 1930s commodity bear market.  A rally to fair value would put the CRB Index at 323.09 (from the current 295.41) and to a standard error above fair value; with the usual definition of a commodity bull market, the level would be 428.98.  However, the chart on the right suggests that a primary component to a major commodity bull market will be a weaker dollar.  So far, the dollar has been mostly rangebound, although the greenback has benefited recently from flight to safety flows triggered by the war.

In conclusion, even with the strong rally seen recently in commodities, market conditions and geopolitical factors suggest further upside is probable.  Yet, the next substantial “leg” higher in commodities will likely require a weaker dollar.  If reserve managers begin to shun the dollar, a decline in the greenback is certainly possible.

View PDF


[1] To be historically accurate, deregulation began under President Carter, but that policy is mostly tied to President Reagan.

Daily Comment (March 18, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! Today’s report begins with the latest updates on the Russian invasion of Ukraine. We then give a brief roundup of international news items and conclude with COVID-19 coverage.

The conflict in Ukraine shows no signs of abating. On Thursday, Reuters news agency reported that there has been very little progress made in peace talks. The two sides are working on an agreement that would allow Ukraine to remain neutral while keeping its military. However, there are rumors that Russia is also pushing Ukraine to formally cede territory in eastern Ukraine. Zelensky has stated that he is willing to accept Russia’s neutrality demand but is unwilling to give up any parts of the country.  The two sides are still far apart, and fighting will likely continue. That being said, there are growing concerns that Putin is considering using nuclear weapons to end the war, an action that may come with its own risk. Eight years ago, Chinese President Xi Jinping signed a pledge to protect Ukraine in the event of a nuclear attack. Consequently, Russia risks a response from China if it does use its nuclear weapons in Ukraine. Although we think a military response from China is highly doubtful, we suspect Beijing will be forced to take some kind of action to maintain its credibility and willingness to honor its commitment to other countries. A non-military response from China could come in the form of a reduction in sanction relief. As a result, we suspect China may offer military support to Russia to dissuade Putin from using nuclear weapons.

Reports yesterday showed that the Biden administration is becoming confident that China will grant Russia military support in its efforts to invade Ukraine. Publicly, China has advocated that it would like to see a peaceful solution to the Ukraine crisis and has maintained that it is not taking sides in the dispute. This position is becoming less tenable by the day as Russian atrocities continue to mount. If China provides Russia with support, the U.S. will likely respond with sanctions. Given that China holds much of its reserves in dollars, sanctions could be very detrimental to its economy. That does not mean China will be deterred from helping Russia. A primary concern for China is that the collapse of Russia will make it easier for the West to form a blockade around it. The development of the AUKUS alliance formed in September of last year further adds to Chinese fears of a blockade. China may want to protect Russia simply to keep the West off its back. From a market standpoint, the situation represents another fat tail event that can potentially be detrimental to equities but may be favorable to U.S. treasuries.

Other Ukraine news

Non-Ukraine related news

COVID-19: The number of reported cases is 463,964,928, with 6,059,216 fatalities.  In the U.S., there are 79,631,708 confirmed cases with 968,329 deaths. For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics. The CDC reports that 696,801,055 doses of the vaccine have been distributed, with 557,644,629 doses injected. The number receiving at least one dose is 254,750,626, while the number of second doses is 216,829,829, and the number of the third dose, granting the highest level of immunity, is 96,232,774. The FT has a page on global vaccine distribution.

View PDF

Daily Comment (March 17, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! The report today begins with Zelensky’s speeches to Congress and the Bundestag. We then give a brief overview of Wednesday’s Fed meeting and the impact it may have on financial markets. Next, we focus on energy and China-related news and conclude with an update on the coronavirus pandemic.

Ukraine-Russia news: In a speech to Congress, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky pushed lawmakers to do more to defend his country against the Russian invasion. Although he would like the U.S. to enforce a no-fly zone over Ukraine, he said his country would accept a surface-to-air missile system as an alternative. Following Zelensky’s speech to Congress, the Biden administration is considering sending Switchblade drones to Ukraine. In a separate speech to the Bundestag, Zelensky accused Germany of prioritizing its economic relationship with Russia over the security of Europe. The comment comes as Zelensky pushes Europe to apply more pressure on Moscow by banning the imports of Russian oil. Zelensky’s warm welcome in the West has worried Russian officials, as Moscow believes it is losing the information war. In a way to drum up domestic support, Putin accused the West of hurting Russian citizens with sanctions and accused the U.S. of promoting Russophobia to bring the country to its knees.

In light of the sanctions, the Russian government appears to be willing to honor its debt commitments. On Wednesday, the Kremlin announced it fulfilled its $117 million interest payment for two Eurobonds. It also permitted Severstal, a Russian steel and mining company, to make a $12.6 million interest payment but warned that Citi may block the deal. Sanctions have made it difficult for Russian firms to secure the dollars needed to repay debt and avoid defaults. Russian fertilizer company EuroChem may have already missed a debt payment. The sanctions have forced the Russian government to impose new restrictions on foreigners trading Russian assets. Without access to the dollar, the longer these sanctions remain in place, the more likely it is that Russian firms will miss a debt payment.

Fed reaction: The Federal Reserve raised rates by 25 bps on Wednesday and signaled that it could raise rates six additional times this year. St. Louis Fed President James Bullard dissented because he favored a 50bps rate hike. The Fed statement showed that the FOMC believes the economy and the labor markets are strong. Additionally, the statement mentioned that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine would likely put upward pressure on inflation and weigh on economic activity. As a result, the Federal Reserve updated its inflation forecast for 2022 from 2.6% to 4.3% and downgraded its median GDP growth projections from 4.0% to 2.8%. Considering the situation in Ukraine, the Fed signaled it was still keen on raising rates and reducing the size of its balance sheet at the next meeting. The chart below shows the updated Fed’s dot plot. The new dot plot shows the terminal Fed Funds rate will be 1.9% for 2022.

Although financial markets responded negatively to the Fed statement, they recovered slightly following Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell’s press conference. During the Q&A, Powell hinted the Fed could potentially view quantitative tightening as a substitute for a rate hike. The comment likely signaled that rate hikes might not exceed 25 bps in future meetings. Our view is that the Fed is correct in its decision to raise rates; however, we suspect that given the level of debt, the Fed runs the risk of causing a financial crisis if it follows through on its plan to hike rates six times this year. As a result, we suspect the Fed may take its foot off the gas if it sees signs of a market turmoil.

Other Fed news: The renomination and nomination of Fed Chair Powell and Fed Governor Lael Brainard were approved by the Senate Banking Committee on Wednesday. In addition, the committee advanced two economists, Lisa Cook and Philip Jefferson, in their bid to fill two vacant Fed governor seats.

Energy news: The U.S. Department of Energy has approved more exports of liquified natural gas. The move is designed to help Europe wean itself off of Russian gas. Although this may not be the ultimate solution, this will likely ease some of the burdens of the switch.  In other news, President Biden urged oil companies to start lowering the price of gas following the recent decline in crude prices.

China news: The People’s Bank of China will take steps to boost its equity market after pledging to calm market concerns and stimulate the economy. There is growing speculation that the central bank will try to cut rates or lower the reserve requirement to meet this pledge.  In addition, monetary easing government officials signaled that their regulatory crackdown could end soon. The developments have had a positive impact on financial markets today.

Other market news: In line with the Federal Reserve, the Bank of England and the Bank of Taiwan raised their benchmark interest rates by 25 bps. The central banks of Hungary, Indonesia, and Turkey held interest rates steady.

COVID-19: The number of reported cases is 463,964,928, with 6,059,216 fatalities.  In the U.S., there are 79,631,708 confirmed cases, with 968,329 deaths.  For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics. The CDC reports that 696,801,055 doses of the vaccine have been distributed with 557,644,629 doses injected.  The number receiving at least one dose is 254,750,626, while the number of second doses is 216,829,829, and the number of the third dose, granting the highest level of immunity, is 96,232,774. The FT has a page on global vaccine distribution.

View PDF

Weekly Energy Update (March 17, 2022)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

Oil prices have fallen to near pre-invasion levels.  The initial rally was driven by short covering, and price volatility has reduced market participation.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Crude oil inventories unexpectedly rose 4.3 mb compared to a 1.6 mb draw forecast.  The SPR declined 2.0 mb, meaning the net build was 2.4 mb.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production was unchanged at 11.6 mbpd.  Exports rose 0.5 mbpd, while imports fell 0.4 mb.  Refining activity rose 1.1% and is now 90.4% of capacity.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

This chart shows the seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  Even though inventories rose this week, they remain below last year and well below the seasonal average.

These charts make evident that the normal relationships between the dollar, inventory, and oil prices are currently broken.  However, the chart on the left indicates the degree of overvaluation has narrowed.  Last week is represented by the circle; we have seen prices move in (the average daily price during the month of March is used for this dot).  Overall, the market is consolidating after the major war spike.  We look for continued consolidation, although we note that the situation with Ukraine remains fluid, and prices could move strongly in either direction on war news.

 Market news:

  • The oil market has been rocked by massive price volatility. As the above chart shows, we are seeing giant swings in the market. The spike we have seen recently appears to be a product of short covering.

As the chart above shows, we have seen a bout of short covering.  Producing hedgers often use short positions in the futures markets or in over-the-counter instruments.  When prices spike higher, a hedged producer will see the value of the short hedges fall rapidly. Eventually, of course, the producer will sell higher-priced crude into the cash market, but until the sale is made, the hedger will face margin calls to maintain the short hedges.  Essentially, a hedger trades price risk for liquidity risk.  The current extreme situation is creating conditions of liquidity risk for the oil industry (metals too, as seen by the LME closing the nickel trading pit) and creating calls for central bank support.

It is hard to justify increased investment into declining demand; the odds of creating stranded assets are elevated.

 Geopolitical news:

  • The biggest geopolitical news continues to be the Ukraine War, but it isn’t the only event that matters. The Iran nuclear deal remains a significant issue.  The Biden administration has pushed to return to the 2015 deal.  A return has looked imminent for weeks, yet the talks remain stalled.  The most recent snag is that Russia wants guarantees it could continue to invest in Iran and avoid sanctions.  It appears that hurdle has been overcome; the agreement narrows the sanctions relief only to areas affected by the JCPOA.  Now the U.S. will need to approve this arrangement.  It remains unclear whether the Biden administration will accept this loophole, but Moscow claims it has “written” relief.
  • With the loss of Russian oil, the U.S. has moved to improve relations with Venezuela. So far, despite last week’s release of prisoners by Caracas, the U.S. hasn’t moved to ease sanctions.  Nevertheless, we might see the U.S. ease up on Venezuela in an attempt to pull Caracas out of Russia’s orbit.
  • While there are reports that Ukraine and Russia are formulating a ceasefire arrangement, the removal of sanctions remains uncertain. And, the disinvestment that has occurred will not likely be reversed anytime soon.
  • As we have noted, the U.S. has been trying to “pivot to Asia” since the Obama administration. The JCPOA was an attempt to reduce America’s commitment to the Middle East.  This signal of withdrawal has raised tensions between nations in the region and Washington.  The KSA has invited General Secretary Xi to visit Riyadh and is in talks to price oil in CNY, a significant departure from pricing oil in dollars.  Pricing oil in dollars was part of the agreement between the U.S. and the KSA after the Arab Oil Embargo.  Although this agreement may be limited (holding CNY in reserve when China has a restricted capital account seems less than optimal), it indicates Saudi displeasure with the path of relations.

Alternative energy/policy news:

  View PDF