Daily Comment (November 10, 2021)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST] | PDF

Today’s Comment opens with key U.S. developments that could have an impact on the financial markets today, including news of a new government crackdown on crime at big companies.  We next cover a range of international news, including the appointment of a new Japanese foreign minister who is surprisingly soft on China.  We close with the latest news on the coronavirus pandemic.

U.S. Regulatory Policy:  An official at the Justice Department yesterday warned that the administration would launch a crackdown on corporate crime in the coming weeks, with a focus on companies that have violated past deferred prosecution agreements or have failed to invest in legal compliance systems.  The official warned that the crackdown, which is separate from the administration’s intent to ramp up antitrust enforcement, would touch some of the biggest U.S. companies.  The statement highlights our concern that U.S. firms are likely facing much greater regulatory risks than they have in many years.

U.S. Bond Market:  A federal working group looking into the U.S. Treasury market’s recent liquidity problems issued a progress report but was criticized for failing to go beyond familiar solutions such as increased transparency and oversight and central clearing.  The report also stopped short of making any policy recommendations and did not suggest a timeline for the working group’s analysis to be completed.

U.S. Inflation:  Yet another basic commodity is getting attention for its rapid price increases.  Prices for ethanol, the corn-based fuel that is a common additive to gasoline, have risen about 50% year to date, with the near-term contract trading at about $2.20 a gallon on the Chicago Board of Trade.  The jump comes as demand rebounds strongly from the coronavirus pandemic, and supply remains constrained.

Belarus-European Union:  As troops and border guards pushed back thousands of primarily Middle Eastern migrants trying to enter Poland from Belarus, the EU accused Belarussian President Lukashenko of acting like a “gangster” in instigating the crisis.  EU officials believe Lukashenko orchestrated the mass migration push to punish the EU for the sanctions it has imposed on Belarus for its political repression.

Japan-China:  Japan’s new prime minister, Fumio Kishida, has appointed a foreign minister who is unexpectedly dovish on China.  The new foreign minister will be Yoshimasa Hayashi, a Harvard-educated, English-speaking official, who previously served as both minister of defense and minister of education.  Like Kishida, he is also a member of the ruling party’s most liberal and pacifist faction, suggesting that Kishida has been emboldened by his party’s win in the late October parliamentary elections.  Therefore, he may feel less need to bend to the conservative factions in the party.  All the same, the conservatives remain dominant in the party and will probably pressure Hayashi to maintain a tough stance on China and continue bolstering Japan’s alliance with the U.S.

China-Taiwan:  In its biannual military strategy report, Taiwan’s defense department said it would try to deter China from taking the island by force primarily by adopting “asymmetric” tactics like sinking China’s large amphibious landing ships with multitudes of small, cheap, fast attack boats.  The strategy calls for inflicting maximum damage on any Chinese invasion force while its troops are embarking on their ships or airplanes and when they are crossing the Taiwan Strait, the times they would be most vulnerable.

  • The strategy of attacking Chinese forces during their embarkation and cross-strait transit phase may make sense, but we have seen little evidence that Taiwan’s military is sufficiently aggressive or skilled in long-distance strikes to pull it off.
  • In reality, Taiwan’s military would probably require a massive transformation before it could hold off a Chinese invasion for any significant time.
  • Besides that, many of China’s options for taking control of Taiwan center on tactics that would be much smaller in scale and harder to defend against, such as blockading or seizing the many Taiwanese islands that lie literally just a few miles off China’s coast.  One example is the Taiwanese island of Kinmen, from which the Chinese city of Xiamen is clearly visible (see photo below).

A view of the Chinese city of Xiamen, Fujian Province, from the Taiwanese island of Kinmen (Source: NPR).

China:  The October Producer Price Index was up a whopping 13.5% year-over-year, far worse than both the expected increase and the rise in the year through September.  The gain in October was the biggest since 1995.  The country’s statistics bureau ascribed the price jump mostly to higher costs for domestic energy and raw materials.  Even though the government can keep a tight lid on China’s consumer prices (the Consumer Price Index was up just 1.5% year-over-year), the big hike in basic materials will surely feed into concerns about higher production costs in China boosting inflation in other countries.

India:  An acute shortage of fertilizers is threatening to disrupt the winter planting season, stoking unrest among the country’s politically important farmers ahead of a series of crucial state elections next year.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 251,054,359 worldwide, with 5,068,233 deaths.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 46,696,230, with 757,417 deaths.  Vaccine doses delivered in the U.S. now total 536,665,505, while the number of people who have received at least their first shot totals 224,257,467.  Finally, here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

  • According to the latest CDC data, 67.5% of the U.S. population has now received at least one dose of a vaccine, and 58.5% of the population is fully vaccinated.
  • Pfizer (PFE, $47.30) and partner BioNTech (BNTX, $226.37) asked U.S. health regulators to expand the authorization of their booster to people as young as 18 years old.  If the regulators approve, the extra doses could provide millions of people with another layer of security as winter drives many indoors where the risk of transmission is higher.
    • Currently, the vaccine booster from Pfizer and BioNTech is approved only for adults who are 65 years and older or are at risk of severe disease and death, including a consequence of their jobs or where they live.
    • In contrast, the vaccine booster shots produced by Moderna (MRNA, $236.85) and Johnson & Johnson (JNJ, $162.51) have already been approved.
  • In France, President Macron announced that residents over 65 would need booster jabs if they want to eat out or make long-distance journeys, beginning next month.  The move suggests all adults will eventually require a third injection against the virus if they want to continue to live normally.
  • In China, where the government continues to enforce its strict “zero COVID” policy, the  Shanghai Marathon was postponed, just as similar races have been postponed in Wuhan, Shijiazhuang, and Beijing.

   View PDF

Daily Comment (November 9, 2021)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST] | PDF

In today’s Comment, we open with a range of U.S. news, including new details on a corporate tax hike in the Democrats’ proposed health, education, and climate bill.  The U.S. news also includes the latest opening on the Federal Reserve’s board that President Biden will get to fill, as well as the Fed’s most recent Financial Stability Report.  We next turn to several foreign news items.  We wrap up with the latest developments related to the coronavirus pandemic.

U.S. Fiscal Policy:  Now that President Biden’s “hard” infrastructure program has passed Congress, there is increased scrutiny regarding the promised health, education, and climate bill.  One tax provision that hasn’t gotten much attention to date is a proposal to tighten limits on the amount of interest expense that multinational companies can deduct from their U.S. taxes each year, based on where they record profits.

  • To boost tax collections, the idea would be to allow interest deductions in the U.S. only to the extent that a company is doing business and generating profits here.
  • Illustrating the importance of the issue, some three dozen major companies sent a joint letter to lawmakers in late October asking that the provision be dropped.

U.S. Monetary Policy:  The Fed said Vice Chairman for Supervision Quarles will resign around year’s end, opening yet another seat on the seven-member Board of Governors for President Biden to fill.

  • Biden is close to announcing whether or not he will nominate Chair Powell for a second term.  Renominating Powell, a Republican, would likely be positive for the markets, but it would also likely spawn pushback from Democrats in Congress.
  • If Biden could name Democrats to the other open seats, it might reduce the political heat he would take from his own party, making it easier to renominate Powell.

U.S. Financial System Risks:  In its semiannual Financial Stability Report, the Fed said a new resurgence of the coronavirus pandemic is one of the biggest risks to the U.S. financial system, especially if there was another wave of mass business closings and further supply chain disruptions that could drive down asset prices.  Among other risks, it also said stresses in the Chinese financial system have the potential to spill over into the U.S.

  • Nevertheless, the report said many parts of the financial system appear resilient.
  • Banks remain well capitalized, and key measures of vulnerability from business and household debt have largely returned to pre-pandemic levels.

U.S. Housing Market:  According to securities advisor Green Street, built-to-rent single-family homes now make up the hottest sector of the U.S. housing market.  In the private market, the sector is now offering expected risk-adjusted returns of approximately 8% versus about 6% for all property sectors.  As a result, many traditional, publicly traded homebuilders have made building homes for rent a major part of their business.

United States-China:  U.S. military planners are testing Israel’s “Iron Dome” anti-missile system as one way to defend Guam against a Chinese attack.  The system would likely be most appropriate against China’s slower-flying cruise missiles, but other systems still need to be developed to counter weapons such as hypersonic cruise missiles and longer-range ballistic missiles.

China Debt Crisis:  Real estate developer Kaisa Group Holdings (1638 HK, HKD, 1.01), which last week admitted that it missed payments on wealth management products that it guaranteed, issued a statement late yesterday asking investors for “more time and patience” as it rushes to raise cash from asset sales to meet its obligations.  Kaisa isn’t nearly as big as the teetering Evergrande (EGRNY, USD, 7.33), but its troubles are significant because they suggest China’s developer debt turmoil is spreading to higher-rated businesses.

  • Meanwhile, Fitch cut Kaisa’s credit rating further to CCC- from CCC+, two weeks after cutting the rating two notches from B+.
  • Separately, the government’s Development Research Center met with a range of mainland property developers and financial institutions to address the crisis,

Japan:  An advisory body Prime Minister Kishida set up to flesh out his “New Capitalism” program recommended fresh fiscal stimulus to help the economy get over the impact of the coronavirus pandemic and improved financial incentives for companies to hike wages.  The panel also recommended subsidies for the buildout of broadband internet in rural areas and support for companies building advanced semiconductor factories.

  • The economic package will total over ¥30 trillion (about $265 billion) in spending.
  • It is expected to be approved by the Cabinet in the next two weeks.

Russia-European Union:  Data show Russian natural gas flows to Germany have increased modestly in recent days, prompting a slight pullback in prices.  However, the increase is still limited.  Europe’s massive gas crunch and high prices still show little sign of being resolved.

Poland-Belarus:  Poland has deployed thousands of troops, border guards, and police to its border with Belarus to stop thousands of mostly Middle Eastern migrants trying to enter the country on their way into the EU.  Poland accuses the Belarusian government of instigating the crisis in retaliation for EU sanctions on the country over its political repression.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 250,511,488 worldwide, with 5,059,656 deaths.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 46,614,298, with 755,724 deaths.  Vaccine doses delivered in the U.S. now total 534,086,695, while the number of people who have received at least their first shot totals 223,944,369.  Finally, here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

  • According to the latest CDC data, 67.5% of the U.S. population has now received at least one dose of a vaccine, and 58.4% of the population is fully vaccinated.
  • Infections are rising again in Europe, as colder temperatures and the fading of vaccine-induced immunity drive renewed caseloads.
    • Germany and some smaller countries in Central and Eastern Europe are experiencing large increases.
    • Germany registered over 37,000 new cases on Friday, the country’s highest daily number on record.
  • Over the weekend, Russia reported a record daily total of 41,335 new cases, as well as 1,180 deaths.
  • While China and Hong Kong maintain their strict “zero COVID” policies, other Asian states are starting to relax their restrictions.  They’re still generally more strict than Western countries, which are largely learning to live with the virus, so the Asian states are essentially adopting a “third way,” a slower route that is midway between harsh restrictions and something resembling pre-pandemic policies.

 Economic and Financial Market Impacts

  • One of the major impacts of the pandemic has been the huge wave of “COVID retirees” who left the labor market and helped touch off the current labor shortage.  Some of those retirees, particularly the more highly educated, quit working because the liquidity-fueled surge in the financial markets significantly boosted their retirement portfolios.  However, it now appears that the bigger share of retirees were relatively less educated seniors who presumably were more at risk if they caught the disease.
  • The post-pandemic inflation surge has driven real interest rates negative or more negative throughout the world, essentially supercharging low policy rates and helping drive risk assets higher.

   View PDF

Daily Comment (November 8, 2021)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST] | PDF

Good morning and happy Monday!  It’s lighter in the morning but will be darker earlier.  Risk markets are modestly higher this morning.  Tesla (TSLA, USD, 1222.09) is making news (and might be lowering the major indices) after Elon Musk had a Twitter (TWTR, USD, 53.15) poll asking the “public” if he should sell 10% of his Tesla stock and pay capital gains taxes.  The public overwhelmingly told him to do so, and shares are lower this morning.  We also note oil prices have dipped on reports the White House will take steps to increase supplies.  We expect the SPR to be aggressively tapped.  We will have more to say on this in Thursday’s Weekly Energy Update.  Our regular coverage begins with the international roundup.  Up next is economics and policy; the infrastructure bill passed.  China and crypto news follow, and we close with the pandemic update.

International roundup:  Russia is getting active, and Iraq’s PM survives a drone attack.

Economics and policy:  Infrastructure passes.

(Source:  Axios)

As this shows, we have seen massive revisions this year.  Much of this is due to the seasonal adjustment process.  Seasonal adjustments are made to take account for the normal seasonal swings in hiring and are based on recent history.  Recent history, unfortunately, has been anything but normal and leads to distortions that are addressed in the revisions.  We also warn that every year, the BLS benchmarks have revisions, and even these numbers are subject to change.  The best advice is to use a three-month smoothing process which reduces the front-month impact and takes the revisions into account.

  • Airlines until recently were offering early retirement to pilots, because the pandemic was increasing the number of pilots ending their careers. Now, airlines are hiring aggressively.  They are also boosting pay for attendants who are willing to work on holidays.
  • One of the trickier areas of monetary policy and inflation is housing. That’s because a house is both an asset and a cost. In the U.S., we use a tool called “owner’s equivalent rent” to parse out the impact of housing operating costs for inflation purposes.  For the most part, central banks are careful about including asset prices in policy aims because it appears as if they are targeting asset prices. Thus, there is great interest in the Reserve Bank of New Zealand’s decision to include home prices in the inflation policy.  So far, most of their policy actions have been regulatory; it has discouraged low down payment mortgages and supported higher density housing projects.  However, if the RBNZ begins raising rates because of high home prices, the increase in rates will likely lead to weaker home prices, triggering declines in wealth.

  China news: 

 Crypto:  Stablecoins and DarkSide are the major headlines today.

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 250,005,427, with 5,052,148 fatalities.  In the U.S., there are 46,488,417 confirmed cases with 754,431 deaths.  For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  The FT has also issued an economic tracker that looks across countries with high-frequency data on various factors.  The CDC reports that 534,081,335 doses of the vaccine have been distributed, with 430,927,624 doses injected.  The number receiving at least one dose is 223,629,671, while the number receiving second doses, which would grant the highest level of immunity, is 193,832,584.  For the population older than 18, 70.1% of the population has been vaccinated.  The FT has a page on global vaccine distribution.

   View PDF

Daily Comment (November 5, 2021)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! A strong jobs report has pushed U.S. equity futures higher this morning. Today’s Comment begins with U.S. economic and policy news followed by several China-related stories. International news is next, and we conclude with our pandemic coverage.

Economics and policy:

  • The Joint Committee on Taxation, a nonpartisan group, estimates that the latest version of the social spending package would raise $1.5 trillion over 10 years. The analysis does not include possible revenue increases due to increased IRS enforcement. However, the score suggests the bill is relatively revenue neutral, which should increase its chances of becoming law. The House is expected to vote on the bill on Friday.
  • The White House released guidelines on Thursday ordering employers with 100 or more workers to mandate vaccinations or require weekly testing by January 2022.
  • The State Department approved a major arms deal with Saudi Arabia. The deal comes as a surprise given the harsh stance the President took against Riyadh on the campaign trail. As a candidate, Biden vowed to make the country a pariah. Over the last few years, Saudi Arabia has been criticized for its war in Yemen and its alleged involvement in the killing of U.S.-based journalist Jamal Khashoggi. In defense of the deal, the Pentagon has stated that the arrangement is intended to ensure that Saudi Arabia has the ability to defend itself from Iranian-backed Houthi airstrikes. It is worth noting that, although the deal has been approved, no contract has been signed.
  • A pact to end the use of coal was met with resistance at the COP26 summit. The wording of the agreement was watered down to extend the deadline to discontinue coal use by 2032. Additionally, major countries including China, Australia, India, and the U.S. all refrained from signing the agreement.
  • Senate Democrats are expected to meet with Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell to discuss his renomination. The progressive wing of the party has expressed reluctance to back his reappointment due to his previous support for loosening financial rules. Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) has already stated she will not vote to support his reappointment. That being said, financial markets have already priced in a second term for Powell; thus, a rejection may have a negative impact on equities. Additionally, there are no obvious replacements if he is rejected. Fed Governor Lael Brainard, the perceived front-runner, has already received pushback from Senate Republicans who have vowed to make her confirmation process difficult. We think Powell’s chances of being reappointed are high, even without the support of Warren. As a Republican, it is likely that his confirmation likely has bipartisan support, particularly among moderates.

China:

  • Beijing announced on Thursday that it was open to negotiations on its subsidies to industrial and state-owned enterprises. The remark appears to be an olive branch to the U.S. ahead of a planned meeting between President Xi Jinping and President Joe Biden. During the meeting, the two sides will talk about deescalating trade tensions. Earlier this week, Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen stated China is expected to meet its commitment under the Phase One trade agreement. If true, it could mean that the U.S. may consider lowering tariffs that were imposed by the previous administration.
  • Republican Senators introduced a bill into Congress that will seek to boost Taiwan’s military defenses. The bill comes amidst growing speculation that China will try to invade Taiwan. It has been widely reported that Taiwan is not capable of defending itself. The bill will grant Taiwan $2 billion in military aid through 2032 as long as the island meets certain criteria.
  • On Friday, China imposed sanctions on three Taiwanese officials in response to the island’s growing push for international support. The sanctions will ban these officials from traveling or doing business in mainland China. Although the sanction will likely not impact these politicians, as many of them have no plans on traveling or doing business in mainland China, the sanctions do represent an increase in tensions between Taipei and Beijing.
  • Chinese bonds have rallied after the People’s Bank of China injected more liquidity into the market as it deals with the country’s debt crisis. The move comes after a second real estate developing company, Kaisa Group (1638 HK, HKD 1.01), also appears to be on the brink of default.
  • Regulators in China have instructed local banks to limit the sale of wealth management products due to the risk it may pose to the country’s economy. Wealth management products have been used by Chinese property developers as a source of off-balance-sheet funding. It is believed that these products helped fuel the ongoing debt crisis in China.

International news: 

  • OPEC and its allies refused to accelerate plans to increase oil production despite cries from other countries. The decision by OPEC not to increase production has angered the U.S., which is pushing the group to produce more oil. As a result, it is expected that the U.S. could consider releasing some of its strategic reserves and pursue ways to punish the group through antitrust laws.
  • Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund is positioning itself to make investments in Chinese companies. The fund has applied for a Qualified Foreign Institutional Investor license. If granted, it will have the ability to purchase Chinese stocks directly as opposed to through a third party.
  • The Japanese government has come to an agreement to provide one-off checks of $880 for each child under the age of 18. The stimulus checks appear to be Prime Minister Kishida Fumio’s first attempt to lay out his “new capitalism” agenda, which is focused on the redistribution of wealth within the country.

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 248,757,793, with 5,032,337 fatalities.  In the U.S., there are 46,335,944 confirmed cases with 751,559 deaths.  For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  The FT has also issued an economic tracker that looks across countries with high-frequency data on various factors.  The CDC reports that 528,775,895 doses of the vaccine have been distributed, with 426,728,092 doses injected.  The number receiving at least one dose is 222,591,394, the number of second doses is 193,227,813, and the number of the third dose, the highest level of immunity, is 21,483,519. The FT has a page on global vaccine distribution.

   View PDF

Asset Allocation Weekly – Is Monetary Policy Affected by Financial Markets? (November 5, 2021)

by the Asset Allocation Committee | PDF

In the 1980s, economic graduate students were taught that the “wealth effect” was minor at best.  It is a behavioral theory that measures the impact of rising wealth on consumption.  In theory, when a household’s assets increase in excess of its liabilities, there should be a tendency for its spending to rise.  However, for much of the postwar period, the impact of asset prices was negligible.  Consumption was much more sensitive to income.  However, around 1995, the relationship between net worth and consumption rose significantly[1].

The relationship between inflation-adjusted after-tax income and consumption is high, with a 69.6% positive correlation.  The chart on the right shows that from 1947 to 1995, the yearly change in net worth and consumption was essentially uncorrelated; after 1995 into late 2019, the correlation jumped to 75.8%.

Why was net worth mostly irrelevant to consumption and then suddenly becoming so important?  We suspect the change in regulation that made it easier for homeowners to tap home equity played a role.  We also suspect that lower tax rates on capital gains likely encouraged financial asset holders to sell assets to fund consumption.

When net worth was independent of consumption, policymakers could mostly ignore the impact of financial market declines[2].  Although the Fed has a mandate to act as lender of last resort, if most of the problems caused by financial stress were contained in the financial system, the FOMC could wait until it was clear that stress was becoming a risk to the financial system itself.  But, if a decline in net worth triggers a drop in consumption, the Fed’s full employment mandate requires it to lower rates to boost the economy.  At the same time, making market rescue an overt policy objective invites moral hazard.

So, does the Fed change policy due to market conditions?  We think a case can be made that it does.

Above is a weekly chart of the fed funds target rate and the weekly VIX, smoothed with a 12-week moving average.  We have placed a line at the 20 level for the VIX.  In the late 1990s, the FOMC raised the target rate despite the VIX persistently trading over 20.  At the onset of the 2001 recession, the FOMC dramatically cut the fed funds target and kept cutting until the smoothed VIX fell below 20.  It only began raising rates with the VIX comfortably under 20.  Its easing cycle started before the recession began in December 2007, just after the smoothed VIX rose above 20.  The FOMC waited to raise rates after the smoothed VIX fell below 20, although it did begin to taper its QE in 2013.  When the first rate hike began in December 2015, the smooth VIX jumped over 20, and the FOMC waited for several months until it fell below 20 before resuming the tightening cycle.  That tightening cycle ended once the smoothed VIX moved over 20.  The easing cycle did begin in Q3 2019, with the VIX under 20, mostly due to a problem in the money markets.  Of course, easing accelerated as the smoothed VIX soared due to the pandemic.

When will the FOMC move to raise rates?  If the history of the past two decades offers any insight, we would look for a smoothed VIX under 20 for a few months before policymakers move to raise rates.  Why?  Because falling household asset prices increase the risk of a pullback in consumption and a rise in recession probabilities.

The relationship of the smoothed VIX to the fed funds target suggests the FOMC does take equity market activity into account when setting the policy rate.  Although this behavior doesn’t exactly mean the Fed targets the stock market, it does pay attention to financial market stability.  So, the path of policy tightening will be, at least in part, tied to equity market volatility.

View PDF


[1] On the consumption charts, the left chart shows yearly change.  The right chart shows yearly change with net worth advanced by one quarter after 1995.  Correlations in both charts exclude the pandemic, which distorts the relationship in both cases.

[2] Real estate assets matter too, but since housing prices rarely fall (of course, the exception was after 2005) financial market declines are more relevant.

Daily Comment (November 4, 2021)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning.  Risk markets are mostly moving higher this morning.  Our coverage focuses on central banks this morning.  The Bank of England was unexpectedly dovish while the Fed is moving to taper.  We look at the impact.  Our regular coverage begins with economics and policy.  Budget talks continue, and the labor markets continue to confound.  China news is next; the food directive remains a puzzle.  The international roundup follows, and we close with our regular pandemic update.

BREAKING:  The Bank of England leaves policy unchanged in the face of rising inflation.  Markets had been leaning toward at least a signal of accommodation removal.  The GBP has fallen hard on the report.

FOMC meeting:  The FOMC announced it would begin reducing the pace of its balance sheet expansion beginning this month by $15 billion per month in November and December and then reassess its position.  The general expectation is that the FOMC will continue at this pace unless (a) strong growth and inflation worries require a faster drawdown or (b) slower economic growth or slower inflation requires a slower drawdown or re-expansion.  In the press conference, the first question was, “is the market wrong to be projecting rate hikes?”  It was a good question, and Powell, showing he has learned how to speak like a Fed Chair, responded but didn’t answer the question.

Our read is that the market has built in 50 bps of rate hikes over the next two years.

The rise in the implied rate of the two-year Eurodollar futures has increased rapidly in the past month.  This level is consistent with 50 bps of tightening.  It should be noted that in 2014 when this level was reached, it took about a year before the first rate hike. Thus, the market seems to be discounting a rate hike by this time next year.

When (if?) policy rates begin to rise, the real test begins.  We have avoided a “taper tantrum” this time because Powell has been able to separate balance sheet policy from interest rate policy.  Essentially, the FOMC is using tapering as its answer to the inflation issue.  If inflation turns out to be “transitory” and begins to fall next year, then Powell will have been vindicated for moving slowly to pull stimulus.  To a great extent, the equity markets, which as we note below, took the taper news quite well, depend on liquidity flowing to stocks and not on real goods and services.

There are two other issues that emanate from yesterday’s decision.  The first is whether this action changes the renomination decision.  The president has indicated that a decision will be coming “fairly quickly.”  We would argue that he is already late.  We suspect Powell would have likely preferred to have waited, but the FOMC was dead set on moving.  Powell’s strongest critics are on the left, but most of the left-wing economists we read are generally supportive of the chair; populist left-wing politicians are less supportive.  But, if there is anyone with any market sensitivity in the White House, yesterday’s market action was exactly what the president should want—there was only a modest rise in long-term interest rates, equity prices rallied, and commodity prices fell.  This morning, we are seeing a rebound in oil and gold, but nothing close to new highs.  That is a good outcome, and Biden should support that.  We think that if Powell is rejected, the financial markets won’t be pleased.

The second issue is the economic impact of tapering.  In general, the history of QE episodes shows the impact of QE has been mixed.  In some previous episodes, ending QE led to lower long-term interest rates.  Our focus is the impact on the money supply.

As this chart shows, the relationship between the balance sheet and M2 is mixed.  For example, during the expansion of the balance sheet in 2013, M2 and the balance sheet moved together.  M2 continued to trend higher, mostly unaffected during tapering and QT.  However, in the latest episode, M2 has risen in concert with the balance sheet, raising concerns that tapering will slow money growth.  If lending increases, tapering won’t be a big deal, but if M2 tracks lower because of tapering, it may reduce liquidity and potentially be negative for financial markets.  This is a risk we will monitor closely in the coming months.

To sum up, the Fed’s nightmare is the Tinbergen problem.  Jan Tinbergen, who won the first Economics Nobel prize, postulated that policymakers need an equal number of policy tools for the number of policy problems.  Trouble comes if a policymaker, for example, has one tool but two problems.  Stagflation is the worst of all outcomes because the FOMC must choose whether it will attack inflation or slow growth.  Although Q3 GDP was sluggish, the current Atlanta FRB GDPNow projection is for 8.2% growth in Q4.  We expect that estimate will come down, but it suggests Q3’s weak growth was probably an aberration.  Yesterday’s ISM Service report is consistent with that position.  The most likely trend for policy is to tighten, but we expect the pace of tightening to be slow, mostly because the labor markets are not close to full recovery… with the caveat that the pandemic has played havoc on the labor markets and thus it is hard to determine if what appears to be the lack of recovery is really a permanent change.

Economics and policy:  Budget talks and tight labor markets continue.

China news:  The uncertainty surrounding the food directive continues, and China is expanding its nuclear capability.

International roundup:  The fish fight is calming down, and Ethiopia is spiraling into civil war.

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 248,243,646, with 5,024,725 fatalities.  In the U.S., there are 46,253,861 confirmed cases with 750,431 deaths.  For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  The FT has also issued an economic tracker that looks across countries with high-frequency data on various factors.  The CDC reports that 525,071,855 doses of the vaccine have been distributed, with 425,272,828 doses injected.  The number receiving at least one dose is 222,268,786, while the number receiving second doses, which would grant the highest level of immunity, is 192,931,486.  For the population older than 18, 69.8% of the population has been vaccinated.  The FT has a page on global vaccine distribution.  The weekly Axios map shows continued improvement, although some states are seeing a resurgence, especially in the southwest.

   View PDF


[1] See what we did there?

Weekly Energy Update (November 4, 2021)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

After touching $85 per barrel, oil prices have dropped on rising inventories and worries about tightening monetary policy.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Crude oil inventories rose 3.3 mb compared to a 2.0 mb build forecast.  The SPR declined 1.6 mb, meaning the net draw was 1.7 mb.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production rose 0.2 mbpd to 11.5 mbpd; production has returned to the pre-Ida level.  Exports rose 0.1 mbpd, while imports fell 0.1 mbpd.  Refining activity rose 1.2%, suggesting we are at the end of the refinery maintenance season.  This build season usually ends in mid-November.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

This chart shows the seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  We are in the autumn build season.  Note that stocks are significantly below the usual seasonal trough.  Our seasonal deficit is 68.4 mb.

Based on our oil inventory/price model, fair value is $63.30; using the euro/price model, fair value is $58.57.  The combined model, a broader analysis of the oil price, generates a fair value of $60.49.  Across all models, the current price of oil is overvalued.  Although supply concerns, especially the lack of response from producers in the light of high prices, is a bullish factor, it is also arguable that prices have mostly discounted (or perhaps more than discounted) the impact of this issue.  If so, we may see a period of consolidation in the coming weeks.

Another factor has been the decline in the SPR.  Since July 2020, inventory in the SPR has declined 43.6 mb, or about 2.9 mb per month.  As the chart below shows, the withdrawal from the SPR has not been a straight line, but if the SPR had not been reduced, current inventories would be below 410 mb, a level that would be consistent with current prices.

(Sources:  DOE, CIM)

The Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2018 mandated 10 mb of sales from the SPR in 2020 and 2021 as part of a 58 mb sales over eight fiscal years beginning in 2018.  Since August, we have seen about 10 mb of sales, which means we may be getting near the end of sales for this year.

 Market news:

  • Although there is clear evidence that ESG practices are reducing domestic production, the administration continues to blame OPEC for high oil prices.  The fact of the matter is that if the world is going to reduce carbon emissions, it will be hard to enact that without demand destruction brought about by higher prices.
  • The current budget in Congress includes several measures that affect the oil and gas industry.  Here are the short takes:
    • Methane fees—the EPA would collect fees that would escalate over time based on leakages of the gas.
    • Bans on new offshore oil and gas leases—would permanently ban new leases on both coasts and the eastern GOM and protect the ANWR.
    • Raises royalty fees—lifts fees on offshore projects to 14% and the onshore rate between 12.5% to 18.75%.  These rates apply to new leases.
    • Increases the minimum bid for oil and gas leases to $10 from $2 with an inflation escalator attached.
    • New per acre fees for Federal leases and on expressions of interest—there will be a $4 per acre Conservation of Resources fee for new production leases along with a $6 per acre fee on non-producing (speculative) leases.
    • Severance fee—a collection of $0.50 per barrel on oil produced from Federal lands or the Outer Continental Shelf and $2 per metric ton of coal output.
    • Other—rental rates are raised, lease terms reduced, and bonding requirements added.
    • Offshore pipeline fees—charge pipeline owners a fee of $1,000 per mile for undersea pipelines up to 500 feet, $10,000 per mile for greater depths.
  • All these obviously raise the cost of extracting oil and gas.  However, it is still not clear they will become law.  For example, Sen. Manchin (D-WV) opposes the methane salvage fee.
  • China is tapping its strategic reserves and implementing rationing in a bid to deal with supply shortages and price increases.  However, there are reports that strategic stockpiles are so low that Beijing may have no choice but to step up importsThat is already happening with LNG.
  • Although Russia continues to claim it is supplying adequate levels of natural gas to Europe, there is evidence it is actually withdrawing gas from the continent.
  • One way EU nations could reduce energy prices to households would be to lower taxes on energy products.

Geopolitical news:

Alternative energy/policy news:

  View PDF

Daily Comment (November 3, 2021)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

In today’s Comment, we open with a slew of U.S. news ranging from a preview of today’s Federal Reserve decision on monetary policy to a new administration antitrust case.  We next share a few thoughts on various global and international issues.  We wrap up with the latest developments related to the coronavirus pandemic.

U.S. Monetary Policy:  The Federal Reserve will issue its latest decision on monetary policy today.  It is widely expected the officials will announce a tapering plan to slow and eventually end the Fed’s balance sheet expansion by around mid-2022.  Chair Powell has stressed that the benchmark fed funds interest rate would likely be kept near 0% for some time after the balance sheet has been capped, but there is still some potential for volatility in the bond market as policy decisions are announced or if investors concerned about inflation and currency debasement try to force the Fed’s hand.

U.S. Fiscal Policy:  As Democrats in Congress continue to haggle over their $1.85 trillion healthcare, education, and climate-change bill, they’ve reportedly come to an agreement on a series of measures designed to bring down prescription drug prices.

  • The agreement, backed by the White House, would:
    • Empower Medicare to negotiate the price of some drugs;
    • Penalize drug companies for raising prices faster than the rate of inflation;
    • Cap out-of-pocket drug costs for seniors at $2,000 annually, including a $35 monthly maximum for insulin.
  • The agreement will likely meet some Democrats’ demands for the bill, but the legislation will still face resistance from moderates like Senator Joe Manchin of West Virginia.  We continue to see a significant risk that no legislation will get done, at least in the near term.

U.S. Antitrust Policy:  Reflecting the Biden administration’s more stringent approach to antitrust policy, the Justice Department yesterday filed a lawsuit to block top book publisher Random House from completing its proposed $2.2 billion purchase of rival Simon & Schuster.  Random House is a unit of Bertelsmann SE (BTG4.SG, 357.00), while Simon & Schuster is a unit of ViacomCBS (VIAC, $37.37)

  • Interestingly, the Justice Department’s suit doesn’t rest on any economic harm that might be imposed on book purchasers by way of higher prices and the like.  Rather, it’s based on concerns that the combination could weaken the compensation paid to authors.
  • In any case, the suit underlines the increasing regulatory risk on companies, as some legal scholars and activists argue that antitrust concerns shouldn’t be limited to just consumer prices and other harms to consumers.

U.S. Politics:  Democrats got taken to the political woodshed in yesterday’s gubernatorial election in Virginia, and they may still lose the New Jersey governorship as well when the ballot counting is done there.  With almost all the Virginia votes counted, Republican candidate Glenn Youngkin has received about 51.0% of the vote to Democrat Terry McAuliffe’s 48.4%.

  • Initial indications suggest the Republicans benefited from a much stronger turnout of their base than the Democrats, although analysts also point to Youngkin’s success in highlighting local education issues and not associating too closely with former President Trump.
  • A key question now is how the Democrats will understand their loss and how they might adjust their strategy going forward.  A prevalent theory among analysts is that the Democrats have become too wedded to “identity politics” and other issues that resonate with highly educated, affluent, white voters in major cities, rather than the economic and cultural issues that are more salient to the legions of lower-middle-class and working-class voters that Republicans have made gains with.  In today’s populism-driven politics, that failure to adjust could help cement Republican control of the federal and state governments into the future.

U.S. Labor Market:  Most union employees at Deere (DE, $355.30) voted to reject a second, richer contract offer and continue their three-week strike against the company.  Workers at two parts plants in Denver and Atlanta, who work under a separate contract, voted to approve an offer with identical economic terms as the one that the other employees rejected.  We still think the vote to reject illustrates how many workers are now increasingly confident in their market power.

  • Potentially, that could point to further labor action, bigger wage gains, and perhaps even some additional inflation pressure in the coming years.
  • We continue to believe that today’s high inflation rate will moderate over time as supply chain disruptions get worked out and pent-up demand peters out, but tighter labor markets, increased regulation, and reduced globalization could well mean that inflation won’t fall all the way back down to the levels common before the pandemic.

Climate Summit:  On the sidelines of the COP26 summit on climate change in Glasgow, former Bank of England Governor Carney said his Glasgow Alliance for Net Zero (GFANZ) group has gotten commitments from global financial firms for $130 trillion of private capital to help achieve net-zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.

  • However, even some climate activists have expressed skepticism about whether the funds will really be allocated to effective climate projects over time.
  • Besides the skepticism on financing commitments, some green energy firms also face more mundane operations issues, ranging from low wind speeds to supply disruptions.

United States-Russia:  In another sign that the Biden administration is looking for ways to ease tensions with Russia so it can focus on other priorities, most notably China, CIA Director Burns today was in Moscow for a meeting with his counterpart at Russia’s Foreign Intelligence Service (one successor to the KGB) and the head of President Putin’s security council.

Japan:  For the first time since 2013, the Bank of Japan and the government’s top economic officials have reaffirmed their commitment to cooperate on achieving 2% inflation.  The move could temper market worries that the goal might be abandoned after years of below-target inflation or that stimulus might be withdrawn now that Prime Minister Kishida has been formally elected for a full term.

France-United Kingdom:  After threatening punitive measures against Britain for denying licenses to French boats seeking to fish in British waters under the post-Brexit trade deal between the U.K. and the EU, President Macron said he would delay the measures in order to “give a chance” to last-ditch talks aiming to resolve the dispute.  Macron’s action seems to have diffused the situation for now, but it still appears that the U.K. is chafing under the trade deal and will likely continue to pursue changes to it in the future.

China:  During a meeting with China’s top market regulator, Premier Li said the government needs to lower fees and taxes for businesses, particularly struggling small and medium-sized enterprises, to counter the country’s economic slowdown.

  • Tax cuts would probably be a relatively healthier way for the government to deal with the slowdown stemming from the country’s energy shortage, disruptive pollution controls, and new restrictions on the real estate sector.
  • However, as in the past, officials could eventually be tempted to roll out bigger spending and lending programs that would prolong China’s debt problems.

Ethiopia:  The government has declared a state of emergency as rebel forces from the northern Tigray Region said they were gaining ground and authorities in the capital prepared for a possible military assault.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 247,740,899 worldwide, with 5,017,139 deaths.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 46,172,312, with 748,630 deaths.  Vaccine doses delivered in the U.S. now total 521,502,845, while the number of people who have received at least their first shot totals 221,961,370.  Finally, here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

 Economic and Financial Market Impacts

  • As the latest wave of infections recedes in many countries and economic activity and prices continue to rebound, negative bond yields are becoming less common in Europe.
    • French, Irish, Dutch, and Swiss yields have all either turned positive or flirted with the line in recent weeks and months.
    • German 10-year bond yields, the region’s benchmark, are still negative but rose as high as -0.07% this week, the closest they have come to turning positive since April 2019.

   View PDF

Daily Comment (November 2, 2021)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning and happy All Souls Day!  Risk markets are mostly steady this morning as the FOMC begins its meetings.  We noted yesterday that it is widely expected the Fed will announce a tapering plan to slow and eventually end its balance sheet expansion.  Economics and policy begin our coverage.  China news is up next. Crypto and international news follow, and we close with pandemic updates.

Economics and policy:  Yellen hints that the debt ceiling may need to be raised unilaterally, and Sen. Manchin (D-WV) puts a damper on the budget.

For several months, the majority of purchasing managers were saying that customer inventories were too low.  For the first time since February, they report that 50.1% say customer inventories are “about right.”  If that trend holds, it suggests that the perception of stockpiles is improving.  On the downside, lead times for production materials are at the highest level since 1979.

  • The ISM information comes in light of anecdotal news. First, the world’s largest container shipping company, Maersk (AMKBY, USD, 15.06) says there is “no end in sight” to the current shipping crisis.  Second, the Ports of Los Angles and Long Beach are enforcing pickup fines of $100 per day for containers that are not moved from their ports.  Given the chassis shortage, the fines are yet another cost to shipping.  Third, exacerbating the problem is warehouses that are full, meaning containers have nowhere to go.
  • Walmart is holding a national supply chain hiring event. What is starting pay?  It is $20.37 per hour.  These positions are mostly warehouse work, but the pay level will likely force other retailers to match it or lose access to workers.
  • A group of NYC taxi drivers is holding a hunger strike to force the city to renegotiate loans on medallions which have proven onerous. The medallions skyrocketed in value until 2014, when ridesharing upended the industry, leaving taxi drivers with loans backed by an asset that has collapsed in value.

China news:  Food comments are worrisome, and Xi may be preparing for the title of chairman.

  • China is issuing directives on food, the so-called “clean plate campaign,” in a bid to ease food prices. Although official CPI food prices in China are falling, that is most likely due to the spike last year in pork prices.  The two-year change in prices is positive, though falling.  However, prices have been high in recent years.

The program also opposes binge eating and attempts to better use food waste.  Beijing is also directing households to stockpile food.  All this looks like the government is deeply concerned about food shortages; perhaps the worry is that shipping problems may lead to disruptions.

Crypto:  U.S. regulators are moving to apply money market regulations to stablecoins.  A recent joint report lays out regulator concerns and recommendations.  We are seeing a gradual adoption of cryptocurrencies; regulation will be necessary for broader usage.

International roundup:  The G-20 met over the weekend, and COP26 starts today.

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 247,215,525, with 5,008,694 fatalities.  In the U.S., there are 46,093,886 confirmed cases with 747,167 deaths.  For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  The FT has also issued an economic tracker that looks across countries with high-frequency data on various factors.  The CDC reports that 518,561,375 doses of the vaccine have been distributed, with 423,005,384 doses injected.  The number receiving at least one dose is 221,760,691, while the number receiving second doses, which would grant the highest level of immunity, is 192,586,927.  For the population older than 18, 69.6% of the population has been vaccinated.  The FT has a page on global vaccine distribution.

   View PDF